Cozy, dimly lit pub known for small-batch beers & draft cocktails, plus late-night American eats.
At a glance
#365 of 608 Bars in New York #458 of 760 Restaurants in New YorkLocalGuideWorld score: 4.30
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★56%
-
4 ★29%
-
3 ★10%
-
2 ★2%
-
1 ★3%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Underdog?
- Underdog is rated 4.3 out of 5 based on 811 reviews.
- How does Underdog rank in New York?
- Underdog is #365 of 608 Bars in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Underdog located?
- 55 Stone St, New York, NY 10004 — 4.8 km from the center of New York.
- How can I contact Underdog?
- Phone: (917) 409-0251 · Website: underdogbarnyc.com
Great value and good variety on the menu. Service could be better, had to find the waiter talking to mates at the bar to get service, twice.
Great spot to meet up with friends! Good vibe...service was very attentive and friendly!
The Underdog was a nice place to have a dinner on the blocked street patio environment. Very reasonable prices and fries were included with the burger which is uncommon in almost NYC restaurants. The burger was fantastic and the fries were really good as well. Nice beer and atmosphere. Will recommend to everyone.
Went there for happy hour with coworkers. I really liked the bar and the vibe. It was too crowded so the servers were often not available. Both my coworker and I found this pink spots on chicken so we called the server. Immediately, the server asked us what we want him to do. I told him I don’t want uncooked food. He said it’s not. After long pause, I asked him to cook more cuz we are uncomfortable so they took it back. Great customer service. Not coming back
We went to the downstairs area and it was really beautiful. Loved the decor and lighting. Food and cocktail menu seemd great, we ordered the fried pickles that also included other fried vegetables and we were there for it. It was really delicious. I won't judge the cocktails because we only had a glass of white wine which we also really enjoyed. My critique is about the staff. I have never encountered such rude, aloof, and unaware group of people. No one even said "hello" when we got there, nor even when we ordered. We sat at the bar and the bartender (woman) was so so rude and short with us and to the couple next to us. There was a very personal conversation between her and one of the servers that was so inappropriate to have in front of patrons. Bartender took very long even though she was right in front of us, to see us so we could order the appetizer that we almost didn't. Every other place in the area was very crowded except for this one and I could tell that service was the issue.
This place has great potential as long as they keep the right staff around. Our visit was on Tuesday 8/23/22
This place has great potential as long as they keep the right staff around. Our visit was on Tuesday 8/23/22
I'm rating 5 stars for listing the beer menu on Untappd to easily find what's highly rated - - the Hudson Valley "Ultrasphere" sour IPA was one of my favorite beers ever.
6 of us shared a bunch of items and drinks. I think the group favorite food was the chocolate waffles. Some foods not pictured. Also, I guess because we sat outdoors under a red tent, some of the photos came out looking unrealistically red.
6 of us shared a bunch of items and drinks. I think the group favorite food was the chocolate waffles. Some foods not pictured. Also, I guess because we sat outdoors under a red tent, some of the photos came out looking unrealistically red.
Me and friend went here on a rainy Friday and the place wasn't that busy in the afternoon. We ordered a few lagers and got their Impossible burger sliders which were really filling and excellent to share between 2 people.
Service was excellent and the team is very friendly and welcoming!
Service was excellent and the team is very friendly and welcoming!
Excellent bar food, good cocktails and beer selection.
Wings, one of the best. They split the sections so they are easy to eat and have more crisp area.
Fried pickles and elote are good.
Cauliflower was not quite as crispy as one hoped
Chicken sandwich and burgers are better than average.
Good for a quick stop.
Wings, one of the best. They split the sections so they are easy to eat and have more crisp area.
Fried pickles and elote are good.
Cauliflower was not quite as crispy as one hoped
Chicken sandwich and burgers are better than average.
Good for a quick stop.
Leave a Review
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Stone street peatonal
View Place
Stone Street Tavern
View Place
77 Burger
View Place
Hph Hospitality Group
View Place
Garden City Deli
View Place
Owett Studio
View Place
One Hanover
View Place
Extra Sauce
View Place
Pizza Gang
View Place
Springbone Kitchen
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Amsterdam Ale House
View Place
Dive 75
View Place
George Keeley
View Place
Lokal Mediterranean Kitchen
View Place
Bar Thalia
View Place
Grand Central Oyster Bar
View Place
Pier 66 Maritime
View Place
Red's Restaurant & Lounge
View Place
The Grateful Den
View Place