LocalGuideWorld – Best Places to Visit, Eat & Stay Around the World
Old West-themed chain known for its steaks, chicken & all-you-can-eat buffet.

At a glance

Rating breakdown

  • 5 ★43%
  • 4 ★25%
  • 3 ★15%
  • 2 ★7%
  • 1 ★11%
300 Commerce Park Dr, New Columbia, PA 17856
Bonanza, New Columbia – photo 1
Bonanza, New Columbia – photo 2
Bonanza, New Columbia – photo 3
Bonanza, New Columbia – photo 4
Bonanza, New Columbia – photo 5
Bonanza, New Columbia – photo 6
Bonanza, New Columbia – photo 7

Quick facts

What is the rating of Bonanza?
Bonanza is rated 3.8 out of 5 based on 1,444 reviews.
Where is Bonanza located?
300 Commerce Park Dr, New Columbia, PA 17856
How can I contact Bonanza?
Phone: (570) 568-1200
Ginny Byers
So much food to choose from! Everything I tried was great. The workers there were cleaning things up constantly. I highly recommend this restaurant!
Krysta Sams
American food buffet, some good stick to your everything comfort food. Just know the usual buffet rules apply, ie quality can fluctuate based upon how long an item has been on the bar. They also do steaks, which have never disappointed.
Lisa M
Our waitress was very pleasant.

The food was ghastly. Simply appalling. We arrived there at 3 pm. I ordered the porterhouse steak medium rare and son ordered a burger and fries. We both added the buffet.

Every item on the buffet looked as if it had been sitting there since Easter. I mean that it LOOKED vile. The sauerkraut literally had a crust on top and the only edible item was the sweet potato casserole. Even that was a disappointment.

My steak was overcooked and disgusting in taste and texture. It was sent back and I was refunded for the repulsive meat, only. I was charged $8 for the baked potato and buffet.

Burger was meh.

Folks..... someone is going to get very sick from eating the "food" at this place. Very sick. AVOID THIS ESTABLISHMENT!!!!!!!
Meredith Carney
1st time I was there I had the buffet. Certain things for the salad had a metal taste to them like the carrots were really bad. The 2nd time was worse not with the salad haveing the metal taste. I ordered sirloin tips sweet potatoe and a Pepsi. I was brought a water. Then the sirloin tips I ordered medium well. Well the cashier haha did not hear me apparently she put medium rare. They came out rare. So I tried to get my waitress haha never came around tried to flag her down a few times with no help even waiving my arms. So I got the attention of another. She took them back finally. So they bring them back out and they are saltier than the salt water ocean or the salt flats (Utah) if you ever been there you will know. No apology no offer of anything to replace it and didn’t offer to reimburse part of my meal. This is the worse place I have eaten and will not return in the future.
Kristy Galloway
Stayed at connecting hotel and didn’t feel like driving anymore so was glad to see a restaurant connected. However it was pretty disappointing. I ordered rib eye to go. Given the price wasn’t bad my expectations weren’t high thankfully. They offered no deserts to go. Being connected to a hotel I would think they provide a more quality plastic utensils when they claim to be a steakhouse. Couldn’t cut the meat with it. It would be different if they had tender steaks not chewy. They don’t provide any type dinner roll. And the baked potato with butter maybe had a tiny tab so it was super dry because they don’t provide any to go. Disappointing is best way to describe.
Jeanne Schussler
The food and price was fair. Most of the staff were friendly and courteous the rest shouldn’t be working with the public. If you don’t like your job, find another. Don’t express it to your customers. If you can’t find your waitress you might see her at the hotel pool chatting with the restaurants
manager, you can find him swimming there for hours, and when your restaurant is suppose to close at 8pm, doors shouldn’t be locked before 730pm, especially when someone calls to confirm closing time just before their arrival.
CHANCETHEBEST
They have good Wi-Fi and a really good restaurant that is built into the hotel.
Leeanna Chipana
Don’t be fooled by some of the lackluster photos here. This place really hits the spot and trust me you will get a lot of food. We were driving back to NY and in the mood for a steakhouse off the I-80. After ordering our steaks we had access to a buffet with yummy southern options. The staff is super friendly and the place is really clean. Reminds me of the Sizzler which I grew up with on Long Island. I’ll be looking for a Bonanza on my next road trip again.

Leave a Review

Do you guide private tours here? List your tour for free – no commission, travellers contact you directly.

List your tour for free
Explore More

Nearby Places

You may also like

Similar Places

Related Places