New York Prime Beef

Tried them out when they had a food truck in Long Island over the summer. It was later in the day so they didn’t have what I originally wanted to order and got the NY strip and fries instead. It was honestly amazing. The taste was so delicious and the meat was very juicy, grilled to perfection. The only sad thing is I never saw them back at that spot. Now that I see they deliver prepped steaks I’m excited to try that next!

Update. Sent NY Prime Beef an email with photo of the steak I wasn't happy with. They quickly replied and they will ship me 2 - T Bone steaks for free on Monday. Customer service 5 stars. Thank you.

I'm leaving only 4 starts overall as my special X-mas dinner moment can't be replaced on Mon or Tues. No one should have received a sub par steak. My advice to buyers is to open the brown paper wrap and inspect upon receipt. The steaks are vacuum packed anyway.

I would recommend NY Prime Beef

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Hit or miss. Ordered 2, 24 oz dry aged USDA prime T bone @ $59.99 ea. For that kind of money I expect to receive what I paid for, PERFECTION but I didn't. Steaks arrived Dec, 24 2020.

Posting a photo of the steaks in a pan just for the pic. Trying to prove that 1 steak was beautifully marbled and came out super tender. The other was barely marbled at all and was significantly tougher. They looked like different cuts of meat. The non marbled steak wasn't even close to being worth $60. In my opinion I got ripped off.

These were both outdoor grilled per directions side by side medium rare.

The steaks are excellent. You can taste the flavor from the aging. It has somewhat of a Brie cheesy taste, so my 11 year old didn't like it (though he loves cheese). The adults really enjoyed the flavor. They were tender and you could see the difference even when cooked. The brisket came a bit thawed and smelled funny, but they replaced it. I would suggest to the company, maybe having the brisket cut into smaller pieces. Will be ordering again.

Strip steaks looked great in packaging, but when put on grill they split into 2 thin fillets that were tough and chewy. Looked like 2 pieces of meat were put together. Not for consumption. I hope i am not throwing rest of meat i ordered out. Happy mothers day! Not a fan!

I ordered the NY Strip 16 oz and the bone-in filet. The NY strip was very good, although not quite to the level of some steaks I normally purchase. The bone-in filet was absolutely not worth the money. It was "gamey" and difficult to cut from the bone. However, I have another order that I have received and will give them a second chance. The NY strip was well-trimmed and quality. The bone-in filet was just plain not acceptable. Let's see what this order brings pertaining to taste and tenderness.

Just Received My Order Today ... First Time Using This Company... Just Made The Brisket Burgers... WOW!! I Cannot Say Enough Good Things About This Place... Priced Right... Great Quality... And Fast Shipping!! This Place Is A Score During These Hard Times! A+

I gave it 5 stars because the steaks are flavorful, but every filet is
only a 1/2 thick. They look like sliders. Big disappointment especially
because I wanted to support local business. After contacting the co. I
spoke to Josh Tanner who immediately sent out a new batch of beautiful steaks at no charge. They stand behind their products and so do I.

NYPB deliveries in all ways.
Quality, Price and Consistency.
Aged to Wagyu.
Coming from a chef, good industry pro of thirty five years and a connoisseur of great things.
They have something for you.
Pork, Chicken and Value you packs.
Step aside Omaha and Buckhead. NYPB is here to stay and conveniently located at Food Center Drive at Hints Point.