At a glance
#2 of 4 Mexican restaurants in Garden CityLocalGuideWorld score: 4.30
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★62%
-
4 ★19%
-
3 ★7%
-
2 ★6%
-
1 ★5%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Mesita Garden City?
- Mesita Garden City is rated 4.3 out of 5 based on 330 reviews.
- How does Mesita Garden City rank in Garden City?
- Mesita Garden City is #2 of 4 Mexican restaurants in Garden City by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Mesita Garden City located?
- 825 Franklin Ave, Garden City, NY 11530, United States — 177.7 km from the center of Garden City.
- How can I contact Mesita Garden City?
- Phone: +1 516-464-2288 · Website: mesitarestaurants.com
The way the fajitas came out of the kitchen 3 MINS after I ordered it is NOT ok. Fajitas IMO should come out sizzling. Looks like they had it precooked, microwaved and served.
The audacity to have a price point of $30 for microwaved food (who knows how long it sat there for) check it out:
-Flavor is not even all that, food was dry.
-Pinch-size portion of protein: chicken & shrimp
-2 tortillas only?! (Also microwaved)
*Had to ask the bartender twice for silverware since the one they gave my friend and I were clearly dirty*
I’m huge on food. Just got back from Mexico actually and this is a complete steal. Terrible job! Will not be coming back.
The audacity to have a price point of $30 for microwaved food (who knows how long it sat there for) check it out:
-Flavor is not even all that, food was dry.
-Pinch-size portion of protein: chicken & shrimp
-2 tortillas only?! (Also microwaved)
*Had to ask the bartender twice for silverware since the one they gave my friend and I were clearly dirty*
I’m huge on food. Just got back from Mexico actually and this is a complete steal. Terrible job! Will not be coming back.
The ambience and service were good. The food was fresh and waiter checked in periodically. Overall good experience.
Great food, service , and atmosphere. The freshly made quamole table side was excellent. Fish tacos and fajitas were great.
Energetic and fun vibe! Great food and great drinks. All drinks were made with real fruit juice and not mix, which makes a huge difference! The tropical drink was delicious. Guacamole was made fresh in the dining room and was very good. Tasty & fresh. “Mexican shrimp scampi” was so so delicious. The sauce on the shrimp was so tasty and the flavors were so succulent! The rice and zucchini made the dish! Shrimp were cooked perfectly. Really cute date night spot!
If I can give this place a higher rating than 5/5 I would. Was absolutely blown away by this spot. Customer service was spot on and we had Valentin as our server. He was helpful and we had so much fun at this spot. The food was so amazing and I recommend getting the queso Fundido and steak fajitas. Also you can’t go wrong with getting any of the drinks. Most dishes are delivered with amazing presentation. So happy we discovered this hidden gem.
Fun spot to visit. The frozen margaritas were strong! You do have to order from the bar in order to get any happy hour specials. All of our parties food & drinks were good. The table service was a bit on the slower side, but nothing unreasonable.
What a gem of a find. We wanted to try Mesita in Garden City and we’re so glad we did! The vibe is cool and everyone is welcoming. We came a bit early for dinner. Reservations are a must as it filled up fast for a Thursday. We had a shrimp ceviche for a starter and was surprised of the large portion. Fresh and delicious. I had the special - lobster quesadillas with a light slaw and my husband had the skirt steak with potatoes. Both delicious and our plates went back empty! Desserts were the tres leches cake and the churros with a Mexican chocolate dip. We enjoyed everything and washed it down with a red (drinky) sangria. Our waiter is Eric - another gem, so friendly, professional and his recommendations were spot on. The staff is great too. Thank you Mesita for a lovely date night! We will definitely come again!
We recently had the pleasure of dining at Mesita Garden City, and it was an absolute treat for our taste buds. From the moment we stepped in, we were impressed by the warm and inviting ambiance of the restaurant, and it was evident that their team was dedicated to providing a memorable dining experience.
The food! Mesita Garden City serves up authentic Mexican dishes bursting with flavors that take you on a culinary journey through Mexico. From the appetizers to the main courses, each dish was carefully prepared with attention to detail and presented beautifully.
The food! Mesita Garden City serves up authentic Mexican dishes bursting with flavors that take you on a culinary journey through Mexico. From the appetizers to the main courses, each dish was carefully prepared with attention to detail and presented beautifully.
Leave a Review
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Muse Paintbar - Garden City
View Place
Joseph Fazzolari
View Place
Waterzooi Belgian Bistro & Oyster Bar
View Place
Orchid
View Place
Primehouse
View Place
Plancha
View Place
Kaji Sushi and Lounge
View Place
Kinha Sushi
View Place
Sushi Ya
View Place
ReLash
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Mexico City
View Place
Mexico City Restaurant & Lounge
View Place
Road Runner Mexican Fast Food
View Place
Cancun Mexican Bar And Grill
View Place
Tamayo Restaurant and Art Gallery
View Place
German's Restaurant
View Place
Tacos El Gordo
View Place
Margaritas Mexican Restaurant
View Place
Buen Apetito inc.
View Place