Modest, come-as-you-are joint serving hearty American breakfasts, lunches & weekend brunches.
At a glance
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★74%
-
4 ★18%
-
3 ★4%
-
2 ★2%
-
1 ★2%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Main Street Bistro?
- Main Street Bistro is rated 4.6 out of 5 based on 1,145 reviews.
- Where is Main Street Bistro located?
- 59 Main St, New Paltz, NY 12561, United States
- How can I contact Main Street Bistro?
- Phone: +1 845-255-7766 · Website: mainstreetbistro.com
We always saw a line out of the door at this restaurant so we decided to try it out. I’m so glad we did because their breakfast menu is so satisfying and well-priced. I had the chicken and waffles which was so delicious and heavy which was perfect when we needed to refuel after hiking around the area. It’s perfect for before or after hikes. Although, the proportions are massive so maybe try the lighter meals if you’re going to go for a hike shortly after. The staff are incredibly kind and frequently check in. This will definitely be our go to eatery after hiking around New Paltz.
We were around the Catskill and decided to check this place out for breakfast as we saw good reviews however the food was very average. I got the huckleberry folic wrap which is one of their popular option, it was ok nothing to rave about, it was very average not much flavor. My fiancé had the pancake and scramble eggs. The pancake was raw not cooked long enough and the egg was bland as well. Turkey bacon wasn’t good either. Their coffee is great though and the waiter was extremely nice which made up for the average food. We will def not return as even the most basic breakfast stuff like we did get was a miss.
We decided to try brunch here based on the online menu and gluten free options. When we arrived our expectations were heightened by the full house of diners and the vast menu choices. Sadly, that is where our expectations ended. We received our coffee in a timely manner; both were lukewarm and the decaf had no taste. Our wait staff was pleasant and answered questions about menu options. I will mention that we then discovered that there were no spoons on the table and only one place setting. While waiting for close to 30 minutes for our food, we sat at a very small table which was cramped and drafty (it's February). When our food arrived the meals were lukewarm at best. The blueberry pancakes were tasteless, dense, and rubbery. The sausage (a 1/8 inch patty cooked beyond recognition) arrived late. The egg white omelette was cold in the middle and overcooked on the ends; the toast was hard and cold. We will not be returning. If we could give this experience less than 1 star we would!
Love this place. It gets quite busy on the weekend so time it well or wait in line. High quality food and nice ambiance in the heart of New Paltz. I was pleasantly surprised to have a pay with QR code receipt. Super convenient.
Undercooked eggs, stale bread, cold food, room temperature coffee, and discrepancies with the check. I will never eat here again.
I have been coming to Bistro for years and the last 4 times I’ve been in it has been progressively worse. Today I ordered 3 poached eggs, all of them were partially raw and served in a bowl of water. When the kitchen broke a yoke and gave me another egg, they charged me for it. The Bacon was so cold that the grease had hardened. On the cold stale bread they put a chunk of butter that stayed hard. The side of ham was tolerable but not close to the quality it used to be. Home fries were cold.
Also on the bill was my girlfriend’s side of pancakes (short stack I think) which they charged as a whole meal.
It’s a shame to see such a local staple go to the wayside. Today they lost 2 previously loyal customer’s.
I have been coming to Bistro for years and the last 4 times I’ve been in it has been progressively worse. Today I ordered 3 poached eggs, all of them were partially raw and served in a bowl of water. When the kitchen broke a yoke and gave me another egg, they charged me for it. The Bacon was so cold that the grease had hardened. On the cold stale bread they put a chunk of butter that stayed hard. The side of ham was tolerable but not close to the quality it used to be. Home fries were cold.
Also on the bill was my girlfriend’s side of pancakes (short stack I think) which they charged as a whole meal.
It’s a shame to see such a local staple go to the wayside. Today they lost 2 previously loyal customer’s.
Don't take chances with your breakfast. This is serious people - and if you really want to be sure, make the right decision: banana pancakes and salmon hash. It's not worth risking a bad breakfast somewhere else. Do the right thing, eat at Main Street Bistro.
The menu here is huge, it took us quite a while to figure out if we wanted breakfast or lunch; everything looked so good!
I got the Trailblazer, which was an eggs benedict with crab cakes. It was really tasty, had a nice spicy kick to it and the eggs were nicely poached. Definitely a meal I'd come back for.
My wife got the salmon hash and her friend got a burger. Both enjoyed their meals as well.
Overall this place has made it to my "will come back" list, and I'm excited to try more of the menu!
I got the Trailblazer, which was an eggs benedict with crab cakes. It was really tasty, had a nice spicy kick to it and the eggs were nicely poached. Definitely a meal I'd come back for.
My wife got the salmon hash and her friend got a burger. Both enjoyed their meals as well.
Overall this place has made it to my "will come back" list, and I'm excited to try more of the menu!
From the moment you walk in, the staff makes you feel entirely at home. It's the kind of place that makes you feel like a regular, even though you're stepping in for the first time.
The menu itself is really big and diverse. We ordered 3 different dishes, each was reasonably priced for what you got, and completely delicious.
Will definitely stop by again.
The menu itself is really big and diverse. We ordered 3 different dishes, each was reasonably priced for what you got, and completely delicious.
Will definitely stop by again.
Leave a Review
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Main Street Bistro
View Place
Agave
View Place
Pho Tibet (New Paltz)
View Place
Frank’s Fresh Pickling Co.
View Place
Hudson Valley Cheesecake
View Place
Lola's Cafe
View Place
Huguenot Creamery
View Place
Bacchus Restaurant, Brewery & Billiards
View Place
Sideshow Kitchen & Bar
View Place
Alpine Endeavors LLC
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Amsterdam Ale House
View Place
Dive 75
View Place
George Keeley
View Place
Lokal Mediterranean Kitchen
View Place
Bar Thalia
View Place
Grand Central Oyster Bar
View Place
Pier 66 Maritime
View Place
Red's Restaurant & Lounge
View Place
The Grateful Den
View Place