Coal-fired Neapolitan pizza & Italian entrees feature at this quaint spot with sidewalk tables.
At a glance
#188 of 605 Bars in New York #101 of 254 Italian restaurants in New YorkLocalGuideWorld score: 4.40
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★69%
-
4 ★18%
-
3 ★6%
-
2 ★3%
-
1 ★5%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Don Giovanni Ristorante?
- Don Giovanni Ristorante is rated 4.4 out of 5 based on 1,376 reviews.
- How does Don Giovanni Ristorante rank in New York?
- Don Giovanni Ristorante is #188 of 605 Bars in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Don Giovanni Ristorante located?
- 358 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036 — 1.7 km from the center of New York.
- How can I contact Don Giovanni Ristorante?
- Phone: (212) 581-4939 · Website: dongiovanni-ny.com
Food was really good and it's a great family Italian place. Close to theater district so good before and after a show .
Went here for dinner on a Saturday night, and they were surprisingly able to fit in a table for two w/o a reservation. We got a cheese pizza, fried calamari, and cannoli for dessert. Food is well prepared, although nothing to write home about. Would recommend if in a pinch.
Fantastic Italian in New York City. This was a last minute decision to take my fiancé here for a date night. Lucky enough we came on a Wednesday night which ended being a night with a live band which definitely added to the ambience. We started with the bruschetta and the calamari, fantastic. The creamy alfredo pasta was amazing, the flavour of the sauce, the texture of the pasta was a dream. We also ordered the Caprina pizza which was such a delight, every bite was super flavourful. Thanks for having us and looking forward to the next time, we’ll definitely be back.
My friend and I walked in after walking around the city and split a pizza and the portobello mushrooms - they really hit the spot. The ambiance is very classic Italian and perfect for dinner. Shiva gave us great service :)
Excellent Italian restaurant. Service very good and food delicious. Atmosphere is relaxed and cozy. Portions are generous. We were a party of 7 and everything worked ok and everyone enjoyed their meals.
This place has a good reputation for a reason. The sauce with the calamari was superb. Pasta and sauce were delicious. The service was fast and extremely nice people. The drinks had a very good amount of alcohol.
A little too pricey for what you’re getting. The food isn’t horrible, but everything was too heavy. Tasted like butter & cheese without flavor.
Above all the service was not great. Took forever to pay at the end. Whenever we asked for something, they took forever to get it. (Would make sense if they were busy, but we could see them just chatting & there were a total of 3 parties at this time).
Won’t be returned, and probably will be avoiding Italian food for a bit.
Above all the service was not great. Took forever to pay at the end. Whenever we asked for something, they took forever to get it. (Would make sense if they were busy, but we could see them just chatting & there were a total of 3 parties at this time).
Won’t be returned, and probably will be avoiding Italian food for a bit.
Great food and portions and family friendly. Gnocchi and cheese ravioli were great. The brushetta was okay. We had various dishes and it was all very good. Reasonably priced and service was good. The decor is welcoming and it used to be an Improv-comedy club with well known acts!
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
461 West 44th Street Parking
View Place
Rose Room Speakeasy
View Place
New York City Marriage Officiants
View Place
Westway Diner
View Place
Marseille
View Place
The PLASA Foundation
View Place
Gregorys Coffee
View Place
Ambassador Theater Group
View Place
BRDesign Associates
View Place
VisualMax
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
The Alice Cocktail Experience
View Place
The Stonewall Inn
View Place
The Upside Bar
View Place
Rockbar NYC
View Place
Dive Bar
View Place
Dive 75
View Place
Emerald Inn
View Place
George Keeley
View Place
Prohibition
View Place
UnderGround Lounge
Related Places
Bars in New York
Bars in United States
Italian restaurants in New York
Italian restaurants in United States
Pizza restaurants in New York
Pizza restaurants in United States
Delivery Restaurants in New York
Delivery Restaurants in United States
Takeout Restaurants in New York
Takeout Restaurants in United States
Pizza deliveries in New York
Pizza deliveries in United States