LocalGuideWorld – Best Places to Visit, Eat & Stay Around the World

At a glance

#3 of 3 Italian restaurants in New City

LocalGuideWorld score: 4.31

1.5 km from the center of New City

Rating breakdown

  • 5 ★65%
  • 4 ★17%
  • 3 ★6%
  • 2 ★3%
  • 1 ★9%
186 N Main St, New City, NY 10956, United States
Norcina, New City – photo 1
Norcina, New City – photo 2
Norcina, New City – photo 3
Norcina, New City – photo 4
Norcina, New City – photo 5
Norcina, New City – photo 6
Norcina, New City – photo 7
Norcina, New City – photo 8
Norcina, New City – photo 9
Norcina, New City – photo 10
Norcina, New City – photo 11
Norcina, New City – photo 12

Quick facts

What is the rating of Norcina?
Norcina is rated 4.3 out of 5 based on 363 reviews.
How does Norcina rank in New City?
Norcina is #3 of 3 Italian restaurants in New City by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
Where is Norcina located?
186 N Main St, New City, NY 10956, United States — 1.5 km from the center of New City.
How can I contact Norcina?
Phone: +1 845-638-8030 · Website: norcinanewcity.com
V D
I waited for my order to be taken, waitress walked away after taking the man's order at my table, leaving me to sit there with nothing. I waited for everyone to finish eating while she came back to check on the man and ignored me. I feel really sad due to this experience and will not be returning.

Edit: Table furthest in the back to the right side. Got there about 5:30 pm.(march 8th) Order: wings, kids mozzarella sticks, penne pizza, 1 drink(alcohol),kids spaghetti,kids drinks.

I attempted to order when the kids second drinks were ordered. I gave up after. It was known by the table that I can't eat gluten so I didn't order pizza. I just played it off so there wouldn't be conflict. Also a proper tip was given as well. I'm not angry by the situation, just didn't have a good experience. I did say excuse me but maybe she didn't hear me. I like my family to have a good time and didn't want my experience to hurt that.

Edit:Also, the man at the table wasn't in good spirits as he decided against finishing the food and wanted it packed up and leave immediately.his facial expression in video reflects that. He put his food in the trash after we left and said that he didn't enjoy being there as the situation stressed him out. In the end...just let your waitress know to ask both adults at the table it they want to order something and not always just cater to the men. It helps.
Jean Barmash
My family orders from Norcina at least once every two weeks, the food is consistently delicious and creative. I love that they always come up with new and innovative dishes to add to their list of delicious regulars.
Gary Parahus
Food was great! And the service was even better
Our waitress Caroline was the best
Taryn Goodman
The food was absolutely incredible here. When we got there, there was almost no one in the dining room. While we were waiting for our food, the entire restaurant filled up with kids and their parents celebrating some kind of sports thing. It became incredibly loud and chaotic. Despite this, the lasagna was one of the best dishes I've ever had. It had short rib and prosciutto in it, and it was worth sitting through all of the noise.
John 71roadrunner
Stopped in for lunch. Abby was on top of everything from the moment we sat at the bar. Hands down the best bourbon selection I've seen at a bar in the tri state area. Settled on a sausage pizza, definitely the best I've had in New City in more years than I care to share. I'm sorry i haven't been here more often but i will be back for dinner at the bar. Thank you Abby.
chrisnjon
Came here for my cousins graduation party. And the service was fantastic. They set us up all right and cozy. We had to reserve 3 months in advance. But I would 100% come back. Pizza was fantastic. And they provide a prefixed menu for 50 people. We had mozzarella sticks, salad, pasta, pizza, eggplant and chicken Parmesan. All very delicious. Loved it
Chris A
The place was amazing. Drinks were top notch, Carina was a sweetheart - and the food was worth every penny spent. Not to mention the wonderful deserts we had. We will be back for sure!
Eyal Golan
Went there for dinner yesterday evening, was Thursday Night with my wife and another couple.
It was suggested to try this place by a friend, I do shopping in stop and shop right next door but never knew this nice Italian restaurant opened.
It was a good decision though. We ordered different salads, different main she’s and all was delicious and made differently from what you are used to see.
My steak was soft and very tasty and really made exactly the was I asked for it to be.
Even coffee and deserts was very good.
Will surly go there again.
Oh and very reasonable pricing and friendly staff

Leave a Review

Do you guide private tours here? List your tour for free – no commission, travellers contact you directly.

List your tour for free
Explore More

Nearby Places

You may also like

Similar Places

Related Places