Brooklyn Fare (431 W 37th St), New York: Photos, Reviews & Location

High-end supermarket with a focus on organic & artisanal fare, plus prepared foods & baked goods.

At a glance

#13 of 138 Grocery stores in New York #5 of 93 Supermarkets in New York

LocalGuideWorld score: 4.49

1.3 km from the center of New York

Rating breakdown

5 ★73%
4 ★16%
3 ★4%
2 ★2%
1 ★6%

431 W 37th St, New York, NY 10018, United States

brooklynfare.com

+1 212-216-9700

Quick facts

What is the rating of Brooklyn Fare?: Brooklyn Fare is rated 4.5 out of 5 based on 528 reviews.
How does Brooklyn Fare rank in New York?: Brooklyn Fare is #13 of 138 Grocery stores in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
Where is Brooklyn Fare located?: 431 W 37th St, New York, NY 10018, United States — 1.3 km from the center of New York.
How can I contact Brooklyn Fare?: Phone: +1 212-216-9700 · Website: brooklynfare.com

No photos to share!.
I love Brooklyn Fare's Produce. Fresh ' tastes. The Brooklyn Fare close by has great delivery people. They are on time, and if there are any issues on my order: they will. call and follow up on what is not clear. 👏 👏 Bravo to their staff!! 💯 💶

John Sanchez 2024 Feb 17

Brooklyn Fare is impressive for its large selection, which it crams into a somewhat small space. The store has many choices across categories, including household supplies and bath/beauty in addition to produce, bakery, canned food, cheese, beer, and international and gourmet products. When I wanted to make fried chicken, I searched the whole neighborhood and finally found buttermilk here. The selection isn’t as wide for meat. Prices: not low. The layout is a bit crazy and sometimes cramped, but that helps make this Manhattan location of Brooklyn Fare unique and full of character.

M Bennie 2023 Dec 15

Brooklyn Fare offers a unique and upscale grocery shopping experience. The store is known for its high-quality and fresh produce, as well as a curated selection of gourmet and specialty items. The emphasis on locally sourced products adds to the appeal for those seeking a more sustainable shopping experience. However, the upscale nature of the store is reflected in the prices, making it less budget-friendly for some shoppers. Additionally, the limited space in the store can make it feel crowded during peak hours, and the absence of certain mainstream brands might disappoint those with specific preferences. Overall, if you're looking for a premium grocery experience and are willing to pay a bit more for quality, Brooklyn Fare is worth considering.

Tammy Smith-Live 2023 Apr 29

I LOVE Brooklyn Fare. They now supply LLOYDS FAMOUS CARROT CAKE. My daughter and I live this as we are from the Virgin Islands and this reminds us of home. ( even though I wish they would start carrying the strawberry flavored as well). The prices are good and similar to Western Beef the previous store. And always clean and friendly. I may sound partial but for them having that cake available means THE WORLD to us. Thank you to the team at Brooklyn Fare West End location… stay awesome!

Robert C 2023 Jan 11

This is honestly the worst place to get your fruits or vegetables. You are blind if you think their produce is fresh. The Metropolitan Community Church on 36th throws out fruits for homeless people that are more fresh that the ones at Brooklyn fare.

Aniko Magyar 2022 Nov 21

Very nice this grocery store. Has so many items and fresh everything. Staff is very kind and are always willing to help you! Online shopping and delivery is also super easy ….

MOT Mark 2018 Nov 26

I can't say enough good things about this place.
A wonderful and most welcome addition to the #HYHK community.
This store is huge and they carry nearly everything. They have your regular brand items and they have most specialty items too.
Lots of selection in many areas, international cuisine, produce, meats, fish, cheeses, bread's, it's really a good spot.
My new favorite grocery store!

stephen raynolds 2018 Nov 25

Great location in Hudson yards neighborhood. The establishment is very spacious. They have a variety of so many things in this supermarket. They carry different brands in a lot of varieties. Cleaning supplies, pets food is just part of their varieties. They have a deli in the inside. Pre made food as well. The customer service was quick and efficient. Big selection of gourmet food. I totally recommend this supermarket. Handicap accessible entrance.