At a glance
#3 of 4 Italian restaurants in Margate CityLocalGuideWorld score: 4.11
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★60%
-
4 ★16%
-
3 ★7%
-
2 ★4%
-
1 ★12%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Saltwater?
- Saltwater is rated 4.1 out of 5 based on 164 reviews.
- How does Saltwater rank in Margate City?
- Saltwater is #3 of 4 Italian restaurants in Margate City by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Saltwater located?
- 9401 Ventnor Ave, Margate City, NJ 08402, United States — 1.2 km from the center of Margate City.
- How can I contact Saltwater?
- Phone: +1 609-289-8078 · Website: saltwatermargate.com
Three of us went to dinner here and each got drinks. The bartenders were maybe 21 and it showed in the drinks, definitely not worth the price. We ordered the toasted gnocchi app but they were pretty burnt, the sauce was good. The dipping oil was gross, no flavor and drops of balsamic, bread wasn't even worth the calories. We ordered the white mushroom and rosemary pizza, it was more than enough to share with the french fries. The pizza was good but extremely oily, the fries were fine. We sat outside after getting our first drink at the bar. It wasn't that busy but the wait staff was scarce and difficult to get their attention. The water was served in plastic cups with a water carafe but no ice. Uncertain if I'd return honestly because of the cost and the kids running the place.
Great food, especially the pizza. It is super soft. so so so soft. They are famous for their square pizza. And that is coming from a New Yorker. Anyways, the staff is cheery in general, but sometimes they make the atmosphere a bit too fast paced; however, the bar is the main contributor to the fast paced atmosphere. Furthermore, the bar is not loud as it goes for bars, so that is good
Absolutely love this place. Best pizza on the island and everything else is delicious. My only knock would be the prices are very high, even for margate standards.
The pizza here is phenomenal. Hands down the best pizza i have ever had. It’s thick, crunchy, just so so good. I get the pepperoni square pizza and I go to heaven every time i bite into it. I gave them 4 stars though because i got the Milan salad with shrimp and for $19 it was pretty lame. Dressing was good but they gave me three medium size shrimp that weren’t even sautéed, just seemed like they took them out of a container from Giant. But i learned my lesson… just get the pizza!
I accidentally left my expensive designer purse on the back of my chair and left the restaurant. My credit cards were in the back of my phone case and my friend drove us there so I didn’t notice right away. I mistakenly paid the bill and walked out without my purse. When I realized my mistake I called the restaurant to ask if the wait staff had turned in my purse I was given the run-around. My car keys were in the purse and I had to get my car towed to the Lexus dealer and it was a total nightmare especially because I live in the Philadelphia area. I guess honesty and helping others has no meaning to this restaurant.
THE BEST GNOCCHI'S we have ever eaten...the Ricotta flavor, wow!.....my mom (almost 102) ate her Entire meal!!
I made a comment to the busboy how picky of an eater my mom is, and she ate her entire meal! He surprisingly brought out the one owner! She, Lori, and her Husband own the business.
My meal was the Paselli, with peas and prosciutto. Mommy's was Ragu with a big Turkey meatball and sausage.
My husband had THE SICILIAN with
Olives, hot peppers, capers, and eggplant in a marinara sauce
Heather got the square pizza with mushrooms and rosemary.
The pizza....something's special about the dough....airy, tasty.....unbelievable!
The owner, Lori, came out to meet my mom, like she was a celebrity! We had a great conversation about FOOD of course!! I shared about my mom's parents coming over from Sicily in 1911. My grandmother was known for making her Big Meatballs! Actually my mom made big Meatballs too. And even tlhough Saltwater's meatballs are made from Turkey for a healthier alternative, my mom and I enjoyed them....the fresh spices they use made a BIG Difference in the hearty flavor.
As time drew to dinnertime, also, we, being musicians, noticed the changeover from a lunchtime Rock to dinnertime with Dean Martin, Frank Sinatra, and a nice blend of popular ballads. Great music playlist, too!!
We will plan to go again!!!
I made a comment to the busboy how picky of an eater my mom is, and she ate her entire meal! He surprisingly brought out the one owner! She, Lori, and her Husband own the business.
My meal was the Paselli, with peas and prosciutto. Mommy's was Ragu with a big Turkey meatball and sausage.
My husband had THE SICILIAN with
Olives, hot peppers, capers, and eggplant in a marinara sauce
Heather got the square pizza with mushrooms and rosemary.
The pizza....something's special about the dough....airy, tasty.....unbelievable!
The owner, Lori, came out to meet my mom, like she was a celebrity! We had a great conversation about FOOD of course!! I shared about my mom's parents coming over from Sicily in 1911. My grandmother was known for making her Big Meatballs! Actually my mom made big Meatballs too. And even tlhough Saltwater's meatballs are made from Turkey for a healthier alternative, my mom and I enjoyed them....the fresh spices they use made a BIG Difference in the hearty flavor.
As time drew to dinnertime, also, we, being musicians, noticed the changeover from a lunchtime Rock to dinnertime with Dean Martin, Frank Sinatra, and a nice blend of popular ballads. Great music playlist, too!!
We will plan to go again!!!
Five stars for the absolute best pizza we have had in a very long time, possibly ever, outside of Italy. Perfectly cooked Sicilian crust with sweet marinara sauce and just the right amount of cheese and spices. We also had the giant gnocchi pillows with blush sauce. This gnocchi is not the typical ridged tiny dumpling, it is much larger and more airy in texture. We enjoyed the gnocchi but the pizza was the star of the meal. The pie is huge and well-priced. For a sleepy off-season shore town, the restaurant was pretty busy. The decor of the restaurant is colorful and modern with attractive art and comfortable seating. Definitely check this place out and without a doubt, order the pizza.
We went to Saltwater to try there almost world famous pizza and we where out of luck. However, we got just about everything else and it was fantastic. The staff was so nice to us. I would say you will not be disappointed with anything you might oder.
I included some pictures to help you.
As always I do not receive any type of compensation or discounts for my reviews. I am just an average customer just like yourself that enjoys value and cleanliness.
I included some pictures to help you.
As always I do not receive any type of compensation or discounts for my reviews. I am just an average customer just like yourself that enjoys value and cleanliness.
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Johnny's Cafe & Lounge
View Place
Tomatoes
View Place
Sofia Restaurant
View Place
Barrels of Margate
View Place
Bocca Coal Fired Bistro
View Place
La Padella Ristorante
View Place
Stella
View Place
Velo Cafe
View Place
Sapore Restaurant
View Place
Agnes Cafe
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Tarallucci e Vino Upper West Side
View Place
Officina at The Wharf
View Place
TESSA
View Place
Osteria Cotta
View Place
Lucciola
View Place
Trattoria iL Gusto Wine Bar
View Place
Bella Luna Restaurant
View Place
Bosphorus Restaurant
View Place
Sorrento's Pizza House
View Place