Upscale American comfort food & craft cocktails are prepared in this homey frontier-chic tavern.
At a glance
#480 of 605 Bars in New YorkLocalGuideWorld score: 4.20
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★48%
-
4 ★32%
-
3 ★12%
-
2 ★4%
-
1 ★4%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Five Mile Stone?
- Five Mile Stone is rated 4.2 out of 5 based on 832 reviews.
- How does Five Mile Stone rank in New York?
- Five Mile Stone is #480 of 605 Bars in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Five Mile Stone located?
- 1640 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028, United States — 4.8 km from the center of New York.
- How can I contact Five Mile Stone?
- Phone: +1 212-933-0913 · Website: fivemilestone.com
Had been before, but outside inside so loud, I could not hear myself think. They need some fabric or something on the ceiling. Loud music added to the noise level. Part of a big group, so I could only speak to one side of our table. Menu has been edited and good items removed from the menu. Had a glass of rose that was perfectly chilled and delicious. I would return for the outside only. Our server seemed to be the only person working upstairs and it was crowded, including a large birthday party. They were fine, but had limited time for us.
Came here for bottomless brunch and wasn’t blown away but it was good. I got the chicken and waffle sandwich, the waffle was super sweet and the chicken wasn’t like a homemade breaded chicken breast, it honestly looked like a frozen piece of breaded chicken. The fries were fine. My friends got the burrito and the breakfast tacos and said they were good. The Bloody Mary, Bellini and mimosa seemed like cheap alcohol but they were both fine
Fun! Surprisingly good food. I really liked the salmon which was crispy and tender with nice potatoes and kale. Servers are pretty attentive and the cocktails/drink selection is great.
It’s a bar, but expected more due to the area. Cocktails mid, food below par, atmosphere dated. Server was super sweet , but overwhelmed with 30 other Guests.
The food was much better two years ago when I first visited this place. The side house salad is horrid. Just mixed salad from a package and horrible old made dressing. The chicken wings were like refried couple of times and tasted like they were from the day before. The oysters weren’t daily fresh. Overall the food is totally mediocre. Very disappointed.
Solid bar with good cocktails. Food was good but def pricey for what you get. Still good quality though
This place really shocked me! If you come around 6pm on a weekend downstairs is very much lively and sometimes even packed. The food was great I ordered a burger and fries…I couldn’t even finish the burger because it was huge but it tasted great. The fries were cooked well also. We also tried the Spicy wings i would say 8/10. We sat upstairs and got to watch the Basketball game which was nice, they also have a little balcony that you can sit outside and enjoy yourself though you can’t really bring drinks out there. Overall I enjoyed myself and I had a great server but I’m sad that I forgot his name but he was also a bartender…hope that rings a bell :)
This place just does it right! So much space, indoors and outside! Food was just spot on. The waiters were so friendly. Everything was delicious and fun. Great place for burger and beer, but the menu has a great all around selection.
One tip, the Korean cauliflower was absolutely incredible! Yummy, unexpectedly tasty and delicious, must try that appetizer. Enjoy
One tip, the Korean cauliflower was absolutely incredible! Yummy, unexpectedly tasty and delicious, must try that appetizer. Enjoy
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Bondurants
View Place
Heidelberg Restaurant
View Place
The Supply House
View Place
The Vitamin Shoppe
View Place
Budapest cafe
View Place
The Fashion Class
View Place
Italianissimo Ristorante
View Place
Not A Speakeasy
View Place
Maz Mezcal
View Place
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
The Alice Cocktail Experience
View Place
The Stonewall Inn
View Place
The Upside Bar
View Place
Rockbar NYC
View Place
Dive Bar
View Place
Dive 75
View Place
Emerald Inn
View Place
George Keeley
View Place
Prohibition
View Place