Compact, no-frills pizzeria with a varied menu that includes burgers, sandwiches & Italian entrees.
At a glance
#5 of 5 Pizza restaurants in New HavenLocalGuideWorld score: 3.41
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★44%
-
4 ★12%
-
3 ★8%
-
2 ★5%
-
1 ★31%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of New Haven Pizza?
- New Haven Pizza is rated 3.3 out of 5 based on 186 reviews.
- How does New Haven Pizza rank in New Haven?
- New Haven Pizza is #5 of 5 Pizza restaurants in New Haven by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is New Haven Pizza located?
- 798 George St, New Haven, CT 06511, United States — 0.2 km from the center of New Haven.
- How can I contact New Haven Pizza?
- Phone: +1 203-624-4444
Open late. Pizza is very good and isn't greesy. The staff is friendly. The prices are really good for the portion. The area is a little dicey, tho.
My boyfriend and I ordered this from doordash. I love how its open late, because it was almost midnight and we were hungry. The pizza came fast, and it was so good!! We should have gotten a bigger size. It wasn’t that expensive either, I recommend this to college students.
Ordered chicken parm which was more like soup. Raw chicken. Just plain disgusting. I should’ve know better by reading the reviews. Waste of $20.
Amazing service! The pizza is affordable and tastes amazing. Ordered picked up and eaten in a course of 20 minutes. They are our go to for our New Haven night outs
I ordered a gyro here and chicken wings and the price was outlandish, especially since I ordered the same exact order before and it came in like 10-12 dollars cheaper. They charged me 6 dollars and change extra to put the gyro on pita bread instead of a wrap, which is the way you make a gyro and I ordered the same thing before like I said and it was cheaper. I always thought their prices were high but I was willing to pay more for the no pork menu, but at this point I rather spend my hard earned money with someone else and just eat chicken. They were my go to after work being I work second shift, they're down the street from me, and the no pork menu, but damn that, I good.
First off I ordered off of DoorDash… never meant to order here. I meant to order from New Haven pizza place in Milford (WHICH I THINK HAPPENS A LOT. PROBABLY WHY THEY’RE STILL IN BUSINESS. )Which is late years better than this joke. Pizza is average at best for a normal town and straight trash for New Haven! 1 out of 10. I’ll give the pizza a 4.7. First and most definitely the last time I order here.
First, don’t confuse this place with the New Haven Pizza in Milford, CT. That place is great. This place, New Haven Pizza in New Haven, CT is horrible. Absolute worst pizza I have ever had. I would have enjoyed a cheap frozen pizza more.
I know they can't be serious. How the hell did they not notice this moldy slice of cheesecake?! The packaging is clear, for goodness sake. Definitely never ordering from here again. Ever. If they can't take a moment to check the quality of their food before it goes out, they shouldn't be in business. This is a BLATANT food safety issue. Makes you wonder how much more moldy food is in their fridge.
Leave a Review
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Pizza Haven
View Place
Mattson Richard H MD
View Place
Partners Cafe
View Place
Pizza at the Brick Oven
View Place
More Than Pizza
View Place
The Shops at Yale at 56 Broadway
View Place
The Yale Bookstore
View Place
Yale University Art Gallery
View Place
Center For British Art Library
View Place
Urban Outfitters
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Best Breakfast and Wings & Hibachi
View Place
Claudia Sanders Dinner House
View Place
Blondies Sports
View Place
Domino's Pizza
View Place
Gansevoort Liberty Market
View Place
Utopia
View Place
Curry Express
View Place
Original Italian Pizza Restaurant Frackville
View Place
Bonchon Woodlawn
View Place