Laid-back cafe with a patio and a pastry counter offering an extensive Italian & American menu.
At a glance
#2 of 4 Restaurants in FishkillLocalGuideWorld score: 4.50
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★69%
-
4 ★22%
-
3 ★5%
-
2 ★2%
-
1 ★2%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of THE TOMATO CAFE?
- THE TOMATO CAFE is rated 4.5 out of 5 based on 719 reviews.
- How does THE TOMATO CAFE rank in Fishkill?
- THE TOMATO CAFE is #2 of 4 Restaurants in Fishkill by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is THE TOMATO CAFE located?
- 1123 Main St, Fishkill, NY 12524, United States — 2.9 km from the center of Fishkill.
- How can I contact THE TOMATO CAFE?
- Phone: +1 845-896-7779 · Website: tomatocafeny.com
Easy, relaxed dinner with good portions and good prices. Family friendly. Will go back again.
Had a great experience tonight at Tomato Café. Their crust is perfection! So good they should be called Crust Café - but I know that doesn't sound right, lol! Service was excellent, atmosphere was chill yet nice, on-tap beer selections were good, prices were right and that chocolate molten lava cake brought me right back to being a kid in the 90's and tasting it for the first time. 👍🏼
A very nice place to stop and grab a bite in downtown Fishkill. The Tomato cafe serves some fantastic sandwiches and pasta in a cozy little cafe setting. The service was fantastic and the setting was relaxed. The side salads and the bread were delicious. My wife absolutely loved her pasta primavera dish and the ability to get it in a smaller half portion was appreciated as we were traveling and unfortunately couldn’t take left overs with us!
Excellent local casual restaurant. We’ve only been here twice in the past five years, mostly recently March 2024. This past visit we had the steak cafe salad, which was delicious. We also split the garlic bread, which was a very smart inventive take on it, cubing the pieces which made it much more enjoyable of a bite rather than ripping apart or gnawing away at a big loaf. Service was friendly and timely. Cute place and nice atmosphere. Nicely located by the restaurants and shops.
From out of town looking for a place to eat and this place popped up for good ratings. Ordered a Calzone thinking to would be good. It looked stunning, but very cold in the middle. I have not had one in a long while, so I google it to make sure it was supposed to be at least warm in the middle. Flagged down a wait or to let them know, they took it and I think nuked it. After they brought it back I paid my bill and left over half of it on the plate. Like it said, it looked like a million bucks, to bad it was cold.
I placed a pick-up order, it was ready really fast and the environment was great. But bread was moldy and kinda killed my appetite a little. Dish was alright, not what I expected but still edible.
Great family spot with friendly service and good food. Traditional Pizzeria with a twist. They have breakfast sandwiches all day (will have to give them a try). You've got your chicken parmesan, but also a Reubens Sandwich. Nice variations on pizza types and sizes. Dessert menu had plenty to choose from. We tried Jane's local ice cream and the fried dough (not a zeppole or funnel cake, but somewhere in between). Powdered sugar or cinnamon sugar. The fried dough was light, airy and not greasy. It's good and deserves a better name than fried dough. How about fritto e dolce...it means fried and sweet! Not a complaint, because the entrance and outside seating are cool, but inside needs a little TLC.Prices were good. Highly recommend.
I had a delicious hamburger with an equally exceptional side garden salad - the house dressing was superb. The burger was so huge that I brought half back to my friend's house. The service was very good until our waiter made us wait 20 minutes to pay after giving us the bill. In any case, the next time I visit my friend in Beacon, I wouldn't hesitate to dine here again.
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Beast
View Place
Sotano
View Place
Imaging Center
View Place
University Orthopedics
View Place
Westchester Medical Center Advanced physician services
View Place
Fishkill Ambulatory Surgery
View Place
Hudson Valley Public Relations
View Place
Fishkill Golf Course Inc
View Place
Farm to Table Bistro
View Place
Oda Restaurant
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Amsterdam Ale House
View Place
Dive 75
View Place
George Keeley
View Place
Lokal Mediterranean Kitchen
View Place
Bar Thalia
View Place
Grand Central Oyster Bar
View Place
Pier 66 Maritime
View Place
Red's Restaurant & Lounge
View Place
The Grateful Den
View Place