Cozy, easygoing wood-and-brick eatery with hefty specialty burgers and craft beers on tap.
At a glance
#54 of 243 Cocktail bars in New York #6 of 76 Bar & grills in New YorkLocalGuideWorld score: 4.50
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★69%
-
4 ★20%
-
3 ★6%
-
2 ★2%
-
1 ★3%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Black Iron Burger?
- Black Iron Burger is rated 4.5 out of 5 based on 3,874 reviews.
- How does Black Iron Burger rank in New York?
- Black Iron Burger is #54 of 243 Cocktail bars in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Black Iron Burger located?
- 245 W 38th St, New York, NY 10018 — 1.3 km from the center of New York.
- How can I contact Black Iron Burger?
- Phone: (646) 476-3116 · Website: blackironburger.com
I'm not exaggerating when I say that this was the best burger that I have ever had in my entire life. Seriously. I love a good mushroom burger, but this Mushroom Truffle Burger was something else entirely. I could taste and appreciate each component individually, but the union was pure meaty mushroomy perfection. I anticipate that one day I will be staring off into space with a smile, daydreaming as I sigh wistfully, my husband will ask what I am thinking about, and my answer will be Black Iron Burger.
if you're looking for a local burger bar that feels and fits like a good pair of work gloves; you know the type, nothing fancy, but solid and you can count on them, then this place is your hangout. I'd come back with a friend or two, just to forget the office for a minute.
maybe a little jaded from West Coast Burger restaurants that are more corporate than character. at least here is more character.
the food reflects that character, even from their motto on their menu.
maybe a little jaded from West Coast Burger restaurants that are more corporate than character. at least here is more character.
the food reflects that character, even from their motto on their menu.
FOOD: much better than other "new york best" places.
• The Epic Burger: very tasty, patty is medium rare and juicy, lots of onion ring in there.
• The Masterpiece: great portion, flavorful. The buns are soft and airy but not mushy and can hold the weights of toppings, it means that's good quality buns.
• Coleslaw: might not good for some people as it not creamy enough but for me it's great for having less calories.
• Sweet Potato Fries: I inhaled it as it was so good, right level of crispy, thickness, salt.
SERVICE: we came in when there's no one there, got the table and food right away. Waitress did great job.
VIBE: classic sport bar vibe.
• The Epic Burger: very tasty, patty is medium rare and juicy, lots of onion ring in there.
• The Masterpiece: great portion, flavorful. The buns are soft and airy but not mushy and can hold the weights of toppings, it means that's good quality buns.
• Coleslaw: might not good for some people as it not creamy enough but for me it's great for having less calories.
• Sweet Potato Fries: I inhaled it as it was so good, right level of crispy, thickness, salt.
SERVICE: we came in when there's no one there, got the table and food right away. Waitress did great job.
VIBE: classic sport bar vibe.
Saw the good reviews and stopped in with a coworker for lunch. Cool spot atmosphere wise with a bar in the back.
Seated promptly and drinks brought fairly quickly with the restaurant about half full on a Tuesday afternoon.
Plenty of options on the menu, and I did the build your own burger with 2 patties, cheddar cheese, regular bacon, and the spicy mayo along with an order of onion rings and a Diet Coke. The burger was oddly flavorless and just noting special to write home about. The onion rings were flimsy, soggy, and looked like something I would have made when I was first learning to cook.
My coworker got the Mushroom Truffle Burger and thought his was similarly bland.
My biggest problem with the place is the price for the result. $35 plus tip for a bland lunch. I’d rather have payed half the price at the smash burger place around the corner (7the st burger) for a more enjoyable product.
Not worth a second visit.
Seated promptly and drinks brought fairly quickly with the restaurant about half full on a Tuesday afternoon.
Plenty of options on the menu, and I did the build your own burger with 2 patties, cheddar cheese, regular bacon, and the spicy mayo along with an order of onion rings and a Diet Coke. The burger was oddly flavorless and just noting special to write home about. The onion rings were flimsy, soggy, and looked like something I would have made when I was first learning to cook.
My coworker got the Mushroom Truffle Burger and thought his was similarly bland.
My biggest problem with the place is the price for the result. $35 plus tip for a bland lunch. I’d rather have payed half the price at the smash burger place around the corner (7the st burger) for a more enjoyable product.
Not worth a second visit.
Build your own burger, the Bleu cheese did not go well with the burger… my first experience but overall it was nice, the staff were friendly and entertain me by sharing some info etc.
Ambiance (4/5): The establishment is narrow and deep with one side with tall tables and the other with lower tables. We ended getting seated immediately at the bar in the back.
Service (5/5): During peak dinner hours, our party of 2 had a wait time of 5 min. We were asked to wait at the bar in the back but we decided to fully dine there. Since we sat at the bar, we had instant beers and ordering service! The bartender was quick and attentive.
Food
Custom burger (4/5): Cooked to a beautiful medium rare. The broiche bun handled the weight of the burger without falling apart. A very solid burger!
Aioli fries (6/5): we asked for them to be cooked well done and they delivered! Their fries are cut nicely thin and they were made with a perfect crunch. The aioli gave a nice umami to an already great fry on it's own. Portion is big enough to share with 2-3 ppl.
Would recommend!
Service (5/5): During peak dinner hours, our party of 2 had a wait time of 5 min. We were asked to wait at the bar in the back but we decided to fully dine there. Since we sat at the bar, we had instant beers and ordering service! The bartender was quick and attentive.
Food
Custom burger (4/5): Cooked to a beautiful medium rare. The broiche bun handled the weight of the burger without falling apart. A very solid burger!
Aioli fries (6/5): we asked for them to be cooked well done and they delivered! Their fries are cut nicely thin and they were made with a perfect crunch. The aioli gave a nice umami to an already great fry on it's own. Portion is big enough to share with 2-3 ppl.
Would recommend!
The meat is great! We had the American and the Masterpiece burger (the name couldn’t be more appropriate!) The staff is excellent! No matter how busy the restaurant is they always find the time to talk to you and help! 10/10 experience! Thank you to Ray and Olivia for making our experience amazing!
A Cozy Burger Gem in Midtown
While being on a business trip in New York, I had the pleasure of visiting Black Iron Burger in New York on a whim, and I'm glad I did. The place is nice and cozy, perfect for a solo diner like myself. I walked in without a reservation in the late afternoon, and I was seated promptly.
I ordered fries, a burger, and a Lager beer. The fries were crispy and well-seasoned, a perfect appetizer. But the real star of the show was the burger - an absolute masterpiece (as the name suggested). The patty was juicy, thanks to the fresh meat and onions, and every bite was a delight.
I must mention that the prices are on the higher side, but that's expected in Midtown, New York. Despite this, I would definitely visit Black Iron Burger again. It's a great spot for a casual, delicious meal. Highly recommended!
While being on a business trip in New York, I had the pleasure of visiting Black Iron Burger in New York on a whim, and I'm glad I did. The place is nice and cozy, perfect for a solo diner like myself. I walked in without a reservation in the late afternoon, and I was seated promptly.
I ordered fries, a burger, and a Lager beer. The fries were crispy and well-seasoned, a perfect appetizer. But the real star of the show was the burger - an absolute masterpiece (as the name suggested). The patty was juicy, thanks to the fresh meat and onions, and every bite was a delight.
I must mention that the prices are on the higher side, but that's expected in Midtown, New York. Despite this, I would definitely visit Black Iron Burger again. It's a great spot for a casual, delicious meal. Highly recommended!
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Intercontinental Capital Group
View Place
Lasting Trend
View Place
Roster Agency Llc
View Place
Mediacraft
View Place
Civilian Magazine
View Place
Pattern Making Studio
View Place
Atlantic Insurance Agents
View Place
Xand Marketing LLC
View Place
Divine Apparel Inc
View Place
The New York Sewing Center
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Amsterdam Ale House
View Place
Dive 75
View Place
George Keeley
View Place
Lokal Mediterranean Kitchen
View Place
Bar Thalia
View Place
Grand Central Oyster Bar
View Place
Pier 66 Maritime
View Place
Red's Restaurant & Lounge
View Place
The Grateful Den
View Place
Cafeteria
Related Places
Cocktail bars in New York
Cocktail bars in United States
Bar & grills in New York
Bar & grills in United States
American restaurants in New York
American restaurants in United States
Hamburger restaurants in New York
Hamburger restaurants in United States
Sports bars in New York
Sports bars in United States
Catering food and drink suppliers in New York
Catering food and drink suppliers in United States