Local caterer's casual counter-service cafe & takeaway serving farm-to-table American eats.
At a glance
#2 of 4 American restaurants in New PaltzLocalGuideWorld score: 4.70
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★77%
-
4 ★15%
-
3 ★5%
-
2 ★2%
-
1 ★1%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Main Course Marketplace?
- Main Course Marketplace is rated 4.7 out of 5 based on 723 reviews.
- How does Main Course Marketplace rank in New Paltz?
- Main Course Marketplace is #2 of 4 American restaurants in New Paltz by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Main Course Marketplace located?
- 175 Main St, New Paltz, NY 12561, United States — 0.1 km from the center of New Paltz.
- How can I contact Main Course Marketplace?
- Phone: +1 845-255-2600 · Website: maincoursecatering.com
The staff and food were just outstanding... We had the lobster and chicken, and the staff accidentally put dairy on both entrees and promptly made out dishes again for us.
Fantastic food at quality prices...great restaurant for healthy food and uncommon customer service.
Fantastic food at quality prices...great restaurant for healthy food and uncommon customer service.
Very limited entrees. Build your own salad option was good. Local drinks and beers are available. Food was okay. Service was horrible. Took forever to get my order ready. I literally thought they missed my order. Had to confirm, and lady was rude. Order your food and take a seat, they will announce your name. Street parking is available. Enough seating. Outdoor deck is available for nice days. Only one restroom. There was a line to use it.
They've become one of my go to take-out. My favorite is their curried chicken salad and their dessert is great too. Shout out to the chef who made the Coconut Panda Petit Gateau recently, so good
Smoked Turkey panini was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. The hanger steak sandwich they do is really good too. Definitely recommend the grilled potato salad for a side. Employees are friendly this is my go to in New Paltz for something quick and easy.
Interesting restaurant style, you order your food and then you get called and you pick it up and find the table. Good menu too, we had duck confit and braised short ribs and both of them were good, buck was my favorite, short ribs were fine as well, but they were a little under seasoned and cold. Nice fresh juice bar. Unfortunately they have mediocre coffee.
Really enjoyed the crab cake salad special today while visiting my son! Crab cakes were excellent and the salad featured avacado, cucumbers, tomatoes, romaine, onion, and a nice light dressing. Highly recommend this place. Tell em Dave sent ya!
The food was good. We had the eggplant crisp sandwich, grilled cheese, and quiche. The service model was strange at best - all (like at least 5) the employees crammed behind the counter and you do everything from pickup to cleanup. I know that’s what probably one thing that makes this a “marketplace”, but the table we sat at was dirty and we never saw an employee come out from behind the counter to address the tables people were using. The atmosphere felt like New Paltz - like I know what I am getting into and what I am here for, it’s still disorganized, but ok. This rating could easily be a 4 if the tables weren’t dirty and the staff seemed more engaged with everything other than the counter.
Great food at very reasonable prices. We had French Vanilla Hot Chocolates, dinner plate specials Salmon and Pork Loin, and for dessert, Hazel Chocolate, Coconut Raspberry Cheesecake, a chocolate walnut cookie, and a chocolate on chocolate chip cookie. All were delicious and beautifully presented. In fact the photos don't do them justice. They were also reasonably priced, at $18 for each entree, I think $3 for cookies, and $7 or less for desserts. I forgot how much the hot choc was. There is no table service, you order at the counter, and pick up food from the counter when you are called. You drop your own trash and dishes, as pictured. Nice place to sit and eat, tastefully decorated with a lighter, brighter main dining area, and a more dimly lit dining area near the counter. Will definitely be back next time we're in the area!
Leave a Review
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Main Course Restaurant + Market
View Place
Delish Frozen Yogurt Cafe
View Place
New Paltz Eye Care
View Place
Descovich Elinor OD
View Place
Pickled Pig Deli
View Place
Village Grind New Paltz
View Place
Village Grind New Paltz
View Place
Garys Pickles
View Place
Little Loaf Bakeshop
View Place
Rabble Rise Doughnuts
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Amsterdam Ale House
View Place
Dive 75
View Place
George Keeley
View Place
Lokal Mediterranean Kitchen
View Place
Bar Thalia
View Place
Grand Central Oyster Bar
View Place
Pier 66 Maritime
View Place
Red's Restaurant & Lounge
View Place
The Grateful Den
View Place