Inwood Pizza, New York: Photos, Reviews & Location

At a glance

#60 of 124 Pizza restaurants in New York

LocalGuideWorld score: 4.33

13.9 km from the center of New York

Rating breakdown

5 ★64%
4 ★19%
3 ★7%
2 ★2%
1 ★8%

179 Sherman Ave, New York, NY 10034

inwoodpizzallc.com

(917) 261-2880

Quick facts

What is the rating of Inwood Pizza?: Inwood Pizza is rated 4.3 out of 5 based on 59 reviews.
How does Inwood Pizza rank in New York?: Inwood Pizza is #60 of 124 Pizza restaurants in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
Where is Inwood Pizza located?: 179 Sherman Ave, New York, NY 10034 — 13.9 km from the center of New York.
How can I contact Inwood Pizza?: Phone: (917) 261-2880 · Website: inwoodpizzallc.com

Reviews (8)

Alden Funkhouser 2024 May 19

A very nice local spot with great food / staff.

Glenda Anderson 2024 Apr 18

Best pizza in Inwood and very affordable. The staff are friendly and efficient. Recommend the pepperoni pizza and bbq chicken. Will be back to try the garlic knots and cheese pizza.

Meilay Joa- Rodriguez 2023 Oct 01

Best pizza around Inwood area, my favorite pie is the Margherita pizza and classic pepperoni 🍕.
We order at least once a week here, you can’t never go wrong, they also have the Sicilian slide some days and is so good!

jacqueline hayes 2023 Jul 16

I literally order from here once a week. The pizza is delicious!. It's made the same way every time and does not disappoint. I'm so glad to have found this place!

Talisa 2023 Jul 06

We’re regulars and order a whole pizza pie almost every other week.
Love the Cheese pie, the Grandma style and the Margherita pie very much!

They make the pizza pie fresh per your request, a cheese pie takes about 10min.

We also got ice cream the other day when it was super hot outside, we were pleasantly surprised with our ice cream scoops on the cone!

We’re very happy to be living around the corner of Inwood Pizza!
Overall good pizza, good ice cream & good service!

Tip: pay in cash

Genesis Salas 2023 May 23

I placed an order through Uber eats. I ordered a regular crispy extra well done slice with pepperoni with garlic, Parmesan, pepper flakes and oregano. Sent a square slice that wasn’t even cooked, I also ordered a beef Patty didn’t give an option to add cheese so added it in the notes and extra well done, Patty was not well done no cheese and it was falling apart… just horrible

Armando Severino 2021 Aug 10

One of the best tasting and affordable pizza spots in NYC. Friendly staff. Check it out if you're here. They also offer outdoor dining. Didn't have cash and they offered payment through Google pay/samsung pay/apple pay. Recommended!