Casual Italian fare with cocktails & wine in a contemporary, rustic setting with patterned tiles.
At a glance
#198 of 254 Italian restaurants in New York #16 of 31 Pizza deliveries in New YorkLocalGuideWorld score: 4.30
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★65%
-
4 ★18%
-
3 ★8%
-
2 ★3%
-
1 ★7%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Siena Cafe • Italian • Bar • Restaurant?
- Siena Cafe • Italian • Bar • Restaurant is rated 4.3 out of 5 based on 681 reviews.
- How does Siena Cafe • Italian • Bar • Restaurant rank in New York?
- Siena Cafe • Italian • Bar • Restaurant is #198 of 254 Italian restaurants in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Siena Cafe • Italian • Bar • Restaurant located?
- 1580 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10128 — 4.2 km from the center of New York.
- How can I contact Siena Cafe • Italian • Bar • Restaurant?
- Phone: (212) 410-5588 · Website: sienacafe.com
We arrived about 5 minutes before our reservation and were seated quickly in the back where only 3 small groups were sitting in the large area. The attention from our waiter to place our initial order was quick, though after that if he or the waitress serving the front walked to or from the kitchen, they focuaed only to where they going without looking around if any customers needed anything, or asked how their meal was. The waiter was pleasant, though spent a lot of his time up front talking to a woman at the bar, or later just hanging out at the bar after the woman left rather than paying attention to his tables in the back.
We waited over 30 minutes for my wife's half dozen oysters to be served. While waiting we had to ask a bus boy for water and more bread. The bread has no flavor even when dipped in the olive oil or butter spread on it. Upon asking our waiter, the oysters were finally served. I have no idea how long they had actually been sitting there waiting to be picked up. It seemed their was mainly one runner bringing out food. Our entrees were served fairly quickly after that. We did enjoy our food and dessert.
We may try it again as my wife did enjoy her half dozen oysters (2 looked kind of off, and they did replace them without any issues) and the mussels in oil with garlic.
We waited over 30 minutes for my wife's half dozen oysters to be served. While waiting we had to ask a bus boy for water and more bread. The bread has no flavor even when dipped in the olive oil or butter spread on it. Upon asking our waiter, the oysters were finally served. I have no idea how long they had actually been sitting there waiting to be picked up. It seemed their was mainly one runner bringing out food. Our entrees were served fairly quickly after that. We did enjoy our food and dessert.
We may try it again as my wife did enjoy her half dozen oysters (2 looked kind of off, and they did replace them without any issues) and the mussels in oil with garlic.
Such a great spot!!! I just hosted a bottomless brunch for my birthday and I couldn’t have asked for a more affordable, cute spot with a great atmosphere and staff. There were heavy delays with transportation throughout the city so a majority of my party was delayed but our server was so accommodating and understanding and we didn’t feel rushed or inconveniencing whatsoever. $32 for bottomless AND your meal is hard to come by in the city, especially in the UES. highly recommend and WILL come back!!!
Had the steak and eggs (modifications can be made) and the bottomless drinks were definitely worth the price. Food came out perfectly and the steak was well seasoned. The staff was amazing! Jamie made sure our drinks were always full and Gaby made sure that everything was going great! Will definitely be back again!
This place is a nice vibe! Service was pretty good. The only knock was that the first pour of water unfortunately led to a spill in my partners purse. Besides that small accident it was a very chill vibe and the food was great!
I love dining here on Sundays for brunch! It’s an amazing place to hangout, eat have drinks and enjoy great food. The food portion is a lot but it is worth every bite. Trust me!
The staff are helpful and friendly! I HIGHLY recommend this place!
Anything you order you will LOVE!
The staff are helpful and friendly! I HIGHLY recommend this place!
Anything you order you will LOVE!
I had the avocado toast around 3pm on a Sunday afternoon after being out playing sports on a mostly empty stomach for the entire morning. The avocado toast was heavenly. Perhaps partly due to my starvation and exhaustion 🤣 (The avocado on a separate plate was an "extra" that I ordered -- $4).
No, but more seriously, the toast had the right amount of crunchiness, the smashed avocado had the right amount of salt and sweetness, and the veggies contributed a nice hint of sourness. Overall, very satisfying.
The iced coffee with milk and no sugar was also delicious. Can one associate deliciousness with coffee? I don't know but that was how it felt 😄
5 ⭐ overall despite a 3 ⭐ for service -- the server didn't do anything wrong, but I just didn't feel very welcome 🤣
No, but more seriously, the toast had the right amount of crunchiness, the smashed avocado had the right amount of salt and sweetness, and the veggies contributed a nice hint of sourness. Overall, very satisfying.
The iced coffee with milk and no sugar was also delicious. Can one associate deliciousness with coffee? I don't know but that was how it felt 😄
5 ⭐ overall despite a 3 ⭐ for service -- the server didn't do anything wrong, but I just didn't feel very welcome 🤣
Nice atmosphere however the music and conversations are very loud. Food is good. Service excellent. Very pricey even for NYC.
Overall, if you are looking for classic brunch foods with simple flavor profiles, this could be a good spot to visit.
I really liked the salmon omelette I had. Classic omelette but it was enhanced with nice smoked salmon and avocados. The salad and potatoes were also a nice touch. Paired nicely with the mimosas we had.
My friends got the breakfast burger and lemon ricotta pancakes, which were both tasty and not over-seasoned or sweet/salty. It seems like this place really likes kept it really simple.
The outdoor seating was inviting, and our servers were very courteous to us both on mimosa and water refills. They stopped by often to make sure we were ok.
I really liked the salmon omelette I had. Classic omelette but it was enhanced with nice smoked salmon and avocados. The salad and potatoes were also a nice touch. Paired nicely with the mimosas we had.
My friends got the breakfast burger and lemon ricotta pancakes, which were both tasty and not over-seasoned or sweet/salty. It seems like this place really likes kept it really simple.
The outdoor seating was inviting, and our servers were very courteous to us both on mimosa and water refills. They stopped by often to make sure we were ok.
Leave a Review
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
First Wok
View Place
Wok 88
View Place
Ooki Sushi
View Place
1577 Third Ave
View Place
Birch Coffee
View Place
Valley Bank
View Place
Naruto Ramen
View Place
Kolping House
View Place
Front Page Photography
View Place
180 East 88th Street
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Tarallucci e Vino Upper West Side
View Place
Cafe Ba-Ba-Reeba!
View Place
Foodistaan
View Place
Floriana
View Place
The House of Kebab
View Place
Mymy
View Place
Cafeteria 15L
View Place
Claudia Sanders Dinner House
View Place
The Spaniard
View Place
Cibo e Vino
Related Places
Italian restaurants in New York
Italian restaurants in United States
Pizza deliveries in New York
Pizza deliveries in United States
Cocktail bars in New York
Cocktail bars in United States
Seafood restaurants in New York
Seafood restaurants in United States
Brunch restaurants in New York
Brunch restaurants in United States
Wine bars in New York
Wine bars in United States
Pasta shops in New York
Pasta shops in United States
Lunch restaurants in New York
Lunch restaurants in United States
Dinner theaters in New York
Dinner theaters in United States