LocalGuideWorld – Best Places to Visit, Eat & Stay Around the World

At a glance

Rating breakdown

  • 5 ★51%
  • 4 ★19%
  • 3 ★11%
  • 2 ★8%
  • 1 ★11%
215 Main St, Niantic, CT 06357
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 1
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 2
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 3
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 4
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 5
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 6
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 7
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 8
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 9
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 10
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 11
Five Churches By The Bay, Niantic – photo 12

Quick facts

What is the rating of Five Churches By The Bay?
Five Churches By The Bay is rated 3.9 out of 5 based on 108 reviews.
Where is Five Churches By The Bay located?
215 Main St, Niantic, CT 06357
How can I contact Five Churches By The Bay?
Phone: (860) 850-2789
Susan Rauscher
Justin our bartender was pleasant and made two delicious tequila cocktails. We were not hungry but food looked delicious and prices were reasonable. I'll be back next year when we vacation again. Nice local craft beer selection.
Sara
We went to Five Churches for brunch on Sunday, this was our second time dining at the restaurant. The first time was decent, no complaints.
This time, different story. We order the mimosa flight which was good, and a spicy Bloody Mary. For food we ordered two Eggs Benedict ($17) and the Italian combo ($16). The eggs Benedict was embarrassing, the eggs were a very weird texture, the bacon was definitely pre cooked bagged bacon, the hollandaise sauce tasted off and was cold and the home fries were straight from a bag. The Italian combo looked good, until my fiancé bit into it. There was a long string of slime, it was absolutely disgusting. The meat was definitely bad. When the waitress came over we told her about the sandwich and even opened the sandwich to show her the slime inside, she immediately brought it back to the kitchen. She did ask if he wanted them to remake it, but at that point, we had all lost our appetite. We didn’t touch our Eggs Benedict. She didn’t ask how it was and could clearly see we didn’t touch it. The Bloody Mary was also terrible, I took three sips and every sip I got chunks of chopped up jalapeños.
Overall is was a horrible experience, our waitress brought the check over, she did take off the combo, but at the end of the day, we ended up paying almost $80 for a flight of mimosas (the only thing we finished). I would not recommend this place to anyone and we will never go back. We ended up going down the road to Fat Tuna and had a great experience.
William Glick
Had an amazing experience here on a Sunday PM. Came in with the wife and our little one. Very good food, quick caring service, and CLEAN. I don’t think I’ve been in a bar or pub that was this clean (keep it up!) The chef (or manager?) came out to check on us as well. Awesome place at a great price in niantic.
Tina S
We have been to their other location and we're excited to try this location since it's closer to us. I emailed them to make a reservation and they were able to fit our large party. We went here during Sunday brunch with my family and it was nice to see how open this brewery is and so close to the water! They had plenty of seating and also have an outdoor patio that allows dogs. Our server was really nice but they seemed to appear to be short handed because he seemed to be the one waiting and serving all of the tables. He greeted us and got us our drinks right away but then it took a while for us to order. When he took our order, he never wrote anything down and got all our orders accurately! We got a few beers like steeple people and pew pew which were pretty good. We liked steeple people better. I liked that they also offered mimosa and Bloody Mary flights. We started with mozzarella sticks which were not on the menu but the chef was able to make it for us which were good. I got the macaroni and cheese burger and fries, which I thought was a little boring. I would add cheese, ketchup and mayo on the burger but the fries were great! My sister got the adult macaroni and cheese which she thought was okay but would be better with breadcrumbs. My husband got the buffalo chicken pizza with blue cheese to dip which was good and had a nice flavor. My father got the French dip and seafood chowder which he said the soup was exceptional, probably the best he ever had. We even got a few more cups of soup to go! My mom got the eggs Benedict which she enjoyed. My son got a cheeseburger and fries and my daughter got the linguine and meatballs and both they enjoyed! Overall, this is a nice place to stop by if you're in the area!
Kristin Brown
Our waiter was very friendly and they offer a kids menu which is helpful. The location is perfect and right across from the beach. The parking situation could be tricky for the Summer since it's a small parking lot. The only complaint I have about this location is that it smelled like cigarettes inside the restaurant.
Donald Olson
Love the New Britain location, tripped over this while out in Niantic. Service was great, beer was pretty tasty, but we really liked the pizza!! It’s brick oven type pizza, thin crust, the sauce was good. The pretzel bites were good too. We would definitely go back!! Oh, and the patio is dog friendly, a huge plus!!
Mark
Good beer, very friendly staff, and tasty pizza. They have a wrap around bar with half of it being partially outside. Additionally, there is plenty of seating and tables outside with a nice view of the Sound. I will say, the inside is extremely bland. The owners aren't from the area and clearly don't care enough to spruce the place up. Too bad, because the staff works hard and I think their management is dropping the ball for them.
Samuel Watson
Went here for an early dinner and a couple of beers a few days back. Prices are about average. Beers selection was pretty good, and I think they’re all from Five Churches Brewing. We were seated facing the entrance corridor and our view was of a wooden barrier which I thought was odd. Service was pretty good. The pretzel was better than the entrees

Leave a Review

Do you guide private tours here? List your tour for free – no commission, travellers contact you directly.

List your tour for free
Explore More

Nearby Places

You may also like

Similar Places

Related Places