LocalGuideWorld – Best Places to Visit, Eat & Stay Around the World
Contemporary Italian cooking served in tony surroundings with arched ceilings & chandeliers.

At a glance

#6 of 11 Restaurants in Montclair #6 of 10 Italian restaurants in Montclair

LocalGuideWorld score: 4.50

0.1 km from the center of Montclair

Rating breakdown

  • 5 ★75%
  • 4 ★13%
  • 3 ★4%
  • 2 ★2%
  • 1 ★5%
32 Church St, Montclair, NJ 07042, United States
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 1
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 2
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 3
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 4
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 5
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 6
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 7
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 8
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 9
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 10
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 11
Scala Del Nonna, Montclair – photo 12

Quick facts

What is the rating of Scala Del Nonna?
Scala Del Nonna is rated 4.5 out of 5 based on 328 reviews.
How does Scala Del Nonna rank in Montclair?
Scala Del Nonna is #6 of 11 Restaurants in Montclair by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
Where is Scala Del Nonna located?
32 Church St, Montclair, NJ 07042, United States — 0.1 km from the center of Montclair.
How can I contact Scala Del Nonna?
Phone: +1 973-744-3300 · Website: scaladelnonna.com
Kalina Kozak
Had to wait to be greeted by a hostess.
When it comes to food, salmon was terrible, huge regret! The truffle ravioli were good.
Impossible to drink their tap water, I wish more restaurants filtered water.
Service was extremely slow.
Won’t be coming again for sure!
Haley Finnegan
I took my parents here for an early weekday dinner. It was a full restaurant. The sister of the brothers who own the place came over and told us we were eating her grandmother’s meatball recipe and she was delightful- so were the meatballs.

Our waiter, however, was so rude. I tried to place an additional order to go two times and each time he kept putting his finger up at me because he was too busy. I finally got in calf the order and he walked away without hearing the rest. The next time I got his attention to place the rest of the order which was about ten minutes later, he said, “I know I know. I already it in.” Without hearing what I wanted to order. At this point I said, “I’m so sorry. Can you please let us know when you’re not busy? I would like to finish the order.” And he took it down, rolled his eyes and walked away. He continued to roll his eyes at me every time he walked by. It was so unprofessional that I will not be coming back here again. It seems to me that a family restaurant like this could do better to hire nicer staff— we all just want to sit and enjoy our food and be taken care of. It’s supposed to be enjoyable. Especially at a family restaurant.
Michael Miller
While the atmosphere is pleasant, the food is lacking. The cost is average for the area and the dining experience is OK, no table cloths, napkins yes, they do not change dinnerware between courses. Service is slow, don't expect water glasses to be filled and noise level is OK.l
K A
Our experience at Scala Del Nonna was deeply disappointing. We arrived for our 8:30 PM reservation, but no one greeted us for the first 20 minutes. Despite our patience, when the hostess finally did appear and we asked about the delay—considering others with earlier reservations were also still waiting—her response was incredibly dismissive and rude. After waiting over 30 minutes without any sign of being seated, we felt compelled to leave due to the poor service. It was an unfortunate decision, as we had looked forward to dining there, but the lack of professionalism from the onset ruined our evening. We went next door and had an amazing experience!
Eiko Ross
Love this restaurant on Church Street in Montclair. Their food is excellent, service is great, ambiance is so nice. I’ve been here many times, quality of the food is always. Every dishes I have tried are good. Reservation is highly recommended as they are quite busy. This is BYOB place.
Fred Twum-Acheampong
The food was all delicious. Sausage was perfectly cooked and seasoned. Pasta had great flavor and all the dishes were filling. Service was a bit slow and they made a few weird remarks to us. The design of the space is very cozy and everything was arranged nicely.
Carly Pisarri
Scala del nonna feels nostalgic. From the moment you walk in this place is so inviting.

The food was layered w flavor and love. Every single dish was perfect. Temperature and flavor.

BYOB is also great - there is a liquor store right next store.

Only thing we didn’t like is that we had to order everything together. Two people of our party were driving in from out of state and were running late so we wanted to order apps for the table and they wouldn’t let us.
Judy Hahn
We were happy to arrive at this indoor outdoor dining, great vibes, hot spot in Montclair. The staff were all working hard. The food was absolutely delicious. We enjoyed fresh pasta, meatballs and the best ever sole. Though full we indulged in the amazing desserts. I was surprised by how great they were. The three gelatin and walnut torte we're perfection and more!! Great night here indeed.

Leave a Review

Do you guide private tours here? List your tour for free – no commission, travellers contact you directly.

List your tour for free
Explore More

Nearby Places

You may also like

Similar Places

Related Places