LocalGuideWorld – Best Places to Visit, Eat & Stay Around the World
Traditional Italian trattoria serving renowned pies & slices, as well as other standard fare.

At a glance

#4 of 4 Italian restaurants in New Hyde Park #4 of 4 Pizza restaurants in New Hyde Park

LocalGuideWorld score: 4.21

0.1 km from the center of New Hyde Park

Rating breakdown

  • 5 ★61%
  • 4 ★20%
  • 3 ★7%
  • 2 ★4%
  • 1 ★8%
1598 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 1
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 2
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 3
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 4
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 5
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 6
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 7
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 8
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 9
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 10
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 11
Pronto Pizza, New Hyde Park – photo 12

Quick facts

What is the rating of Pronto Pizza?
Pronto Pizza is rated 4.2 out of 5 based on 331 reviews.
How does Pronto Pizza rank in New Hyde Park?
Pronto Pizza is #4 of 4 Italian restaurants in New Hyde Park by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
Where is Pronto Pizza located?
1598 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States — 0.1 km from the center of New Hyde Park.
How can I contact Pronto Pizza?
Phone: +1 516-358-2010 · Website: pronto-umbertos.com
Beth Bocian
Food was excellent. Waiter was attentive and service was fast. We shared a price fix special. Plenty of food for the two of us. Overall an excellent experience.
Bernard Granum (NDP KING)
Best pizza in the area hands down, I come here almost every day for lunch!
1ssaa
Veggie Pizza: Mixed Reaction.
The place is setup as Umberto overflow, and is very much that.
Broken into two sections. Bare bones pizza nook and sort-of fine dining room, with a lone, friendly, server stretching it to the best of his ability (missed filling the soft drink order; wonder how restaurants never miss alcoholic beverage orders, though).
The veggie pizza came with raw broccoli, tomatoes and heavy clumps of boiled (or thawed?) spinach on a soggy pie. Completely off-putting. Dinner plates were oven warmed, though.
One expects a thin crust slice to hold its character when folded New York style, and not droop.

We somehow stashed slice apice, took the rest home, gave it oven treatment, and it was much better.
For now, inclined to pin it on communication gap; will give it another try, after courage is restored.
Quantity-wise, value for money.
Dil Singh
Place is solid

Parking available

The main older guy upfront with glasses, makes it his mission to greet everyone.

He treats everyone fairly and respectfully

Food is consistently good
zhang Mia
This is the salad they give me today !
Very bad !
Vegetables not wash !
It's withered, it's rotten, and it's in there.
Luke Ruiz
My experience was really bad at prontos. My father is a prontos and pizza fanatic lover. He loves his pizza and soda , he enjoys going out and sitting down and enjoying his pizza and food. Sad to say when my family was at prontos the service was really bad. It took about a hour and 45 minutes for the food to come out that’s almost 2 hours of waiting at the table doing nothing. And there is absolutely no tv in the dining area in the back. They kept telling us it will come out soon but it took a very long time . The samon didn’t really even taste like samon and the pasta was alright. After all of this my dad was really sad that they let him down. It was also really hot in the room . They brought us the bread out and there was bugs literally crawling out of the basket and eating our bread . We didn’t want anymore bread after that and left it untouched. My dad got some type of steak veal. This was not cooked right at all my dad took a bite and started gagging. He told me after he wishes he stuck with the pasta and meatballs . My sister only ordered one slice that was so burnt it had burnt circles all over it and tasted like straight up charcoal. We were very disappointed because my father loves going to prontos at least 3 times a week. His loyalty to pizza
Places now definitely changed. he will be going to Gino’s and prevents from now on.
Matt Don
Excellent pizza and super professional customer service. Restaurant is super clean and pizza always fresh and tasty. The regular pizza is always good as is the grandma pizza. I enjoy relaxing here enjoying my pizza and watching a soccer game on the big screen. Very chill atmosphere. Highly recommended.
Avid Writer
Good quality food, nice quaint little Italian Restaurant. They do good pizza too but it's been awhile since I had it. We like the special nights, pasta and chicken. You get to pick a pasta dish and you get salad and a coffee and cheesecake included. The ala Vodka was really good. The cheesecake was the Italian style made with Ricotta, very thick and firm with a good taste and a hint of lemon.

Leave a Review

Do you guide private tours here? List your tour for free – no commission, travellers contact you directly.

List your tour for free
Explore More

Nearby Places

You may also like

Similar Places

Related Places