At a glance
#2 of 4 Bars in Dedham #8 of 10 Restaurants in DedhamLocalGuideWorld score: 4.02
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★50%
-
4 ★22%
-
3 ★11%
-
2 ★10%
-
1 ★8%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Horse Thieves Tavern?
- Horse Thieves Tavern is rated 4.0 out of 5 based on 167 reviews.
- How does Horse Thieves Tavern rank in Dedham?
- Horse Thieves Tavern is #2 of 4 Bars in Dedham by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Horse Thieves Tavern located?
- 585 High St, Dedham, MA 02026 — 1.4 km from the center of Dedham.
- How can I contact Horse Thieves Tavern?
- Phone: (781) 708-9185 · Website: horsethievestavern.com
Really wanted to love it. Menu looked great and the food tasted good but the brussel sprouts were so tough and the corn bread was doughy. So disappointed. The service started great and I can tell there are some good people there but we happened to get the worst service and there wasn’t even that many people but the place was so loud you couldn’t even talk to someone next to you. The waiter asked if my husband wanted another drink but that never came. We only were able to eat one of dishes and ended up paying $80 dollars. Just disappointing.
I will give them a 5 star just because the person attending us was very nice. It is also hard to put down a local business. My reviews is in hope they fix some of the things other people have mentioned in their reviews. One of them is the Chilli. I think the chilli gots to go, or change the recipe of it. My wife had it and gave me a taste just to see what I think. Was cold, and no taste at all. Also my draft beer was warm.
No complaints for my chicken sandwich. Was very tasty overall with the fries.
Told them about the cold chilli and she offered a complimentary apple pie, witch was nice, but cold too. :(
Today's experience wont keep us from visiting again. We support local businesses and my review is not to knock them down, but to give constructive criticism.
Changed my review to one star. Went back and it was the same thing.
No complaints for my chicken sandwich. Was very tasty overall with the fries.
Told them about the cold chilli and she offered a complimentary apple pie, witch was nice, but cold too. :(
Today's experience wont keep us from visiting again. We support local businesses and my review is not to knock them down, but to give constructive criticism.
Changed my review to one star. Went back and it was the same thing.
Second visit where we were disappointed. Clam chowder- watery and tasted like nothing. Fish & chips- it was like breaded scraps of fish (like 3-4 tiny pieces on the edge of the plate of fries) and the slaw flavor was straight acidic/tangy nothing else- like out of balance in a way that does not taste good. Shepherd’s pie- barely anything there below the potatoes, the meat and veggies that were there tasted like absolutely nothing. It was very odd overall. Vibe of the place is great so we were excited- it was just a very odd thing to have every last thing on your table taste like literally nothing (except the fries). This could’ve been a bad night for them so I’m not intending to hit them too hard in rating but given it’s the second time and similar experiences, folks should know. I’d come here for a drink but nothing other than that going forward.
Cozy bar, very friendly atmosphere and a good selection of drinks.
The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable, they recommended different beers and wines. Their cocktails selection is limited, buy they will try to help you out. If you want something that they just don't have they will suggest something similar. Also we had a small bite/snack and it was delicious 😋🤤
Will go back again whenever/if I am in the area.
The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable, they recommended different beers and wines. Their cocktails selection is limited, buy they will try to help you out. If you want something that they just don't have they will suggest something similar. Also we had a small bite/snack and it was delicious 😋🤤
Will go back again whenever/if I am in the area.
First time trying this restaurant. Love the thin fries. The turkey chili and korean fried chicken burger was delicious. Wish that there were dessert available but the time i went the staff told us dessert were not available at the time.
Conveniently located with lots of parking nearby, this place has a good vibe, some tasty food and decent enough drinks. Service is attentive quick and efficient.
The corn bread was fantastic - the main course was OK and then the desserts were very good.
The shepherd pie for example had lots of potatoes and very little meat and the salmon was dry - over done.
But desserts all hit the spot and in balance we left rather pleased with the experience.
The corn bread was fantastic - the main course was OK and then the desserts were very good.
The shepherd pie for example had lots of potatoes and very little meat and the salmon was dry - over done.
But desserts all hit the spot and in balance we left rather pleased with the experience.
-Opened a few months ago- I went around 2p and got the Korean Fried Chicken Sandwich, fantastic! The prices & food are are on point. The staff are all super nice. Menus for both lunch & dinner are simple (1page). But yet there's something for everyone. They have a full bar. Even at 2p you could feel that this place is alive. So if you are in Dedham Sq swing on by. For a nice new surprise. -Support your local businesses-
Another new addition to dedham square. Its a great spot. Good draft list with really good food. The timing on the food delivery was a little off. The apps and main course came out basically at the same time. Thats the only small gripe I can think of. Other than that it was absolutely great. I will definitely be back again for more.
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
The Grateful Dedham Diner
View Place
Essential Advanced Skincare and Medspa
View Place
Dedham Community Theatre
View Place
Cathay Kitchen
View Place
Terra Spa
View Place
Kouzina Estiatorio
View Place
Thai Wellness Massage
View Place
Dedham Medical Aesthetics
View Place
La Taqueria
View Place
Eggs and Thai Cafe
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
The Alice Cocktail Experience
View Place
The Stonewall Inn
View Place
The Upside Bar
View Place
Rockbar NYC
View Place
Dive Bar
View Place
Dive 75
View Place
Emerald Inn
View Place
George Keeley
View Place
Prohibition
View Place