LocalGuideWorld – Best Places to Visit, Eat & Stay Around the World
Cash-only neighborhood saloon offering drinks, American pub grub & more in an unpretentious space.

At a glance

#5 of 13 Bar & grills in Indianapolis

LocalGuideWorld score: 4.58

7.4 km from the center of Indianapolis

Rating breakdown

  • 5 ★76%
  • 4 ★16%
  • 3 ★5%
  • 2 ★2%
  • 1 ★2%
5170 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205, United States
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 1
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 2
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 3
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 4
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 5
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 6
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 7
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 8
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 9
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 10
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 11
Red Key Tavern, Indianapolis – photo 12

Quick facts

What is the rating of Red Key Tavern?
Red Key Tavern is rated 4.6 out of 5 based on 304 reviews.
How does Red Key Tavern rank in Indianapolis?
Red Key Tavern is #5 of 13 Bar & grills in Indianapolis by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
Where is Red Key Tavern located?
5170 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205, United States — 7.4 km from the center of Indianapolis.
How can I contact Red Key Tavern?
Phone: +1 317-283-4601 · Website: redkeytavern.com
Christiana Watson
Really, chill spot to stop in for a simple beer and satisfying bite to eat! The few menu items available are really well made and yummy! Nothing fancy, just plain good! Great cheeseburgers! I personally enjoyed the BLT! I love the location and the staff is great! A lot of the Broad Ripple old timers know this low key casual spot .A relaxed and easy atmosphere! Highly recommend to add this stop to your out and about !
Karen Lucas
Chris always greets you with a smile! And Davey and The Midnights provide incredible music.
Abbie G
I went here for my very first drink. Seems like a decent bar despite that I don’t have much perspective on bars! Our waitress was very nice and popped around here and there. The environment was pretty average, but not bad! The prices were really nice!
Todd Helmold
These burgers are one of the best in town, only made by Sully. The atmosphere is great, love the model plans hanging from the ceiling. It is cash only so make sure you are prepared.
Ryan Sheridan
No hookah here so disregard anything regarding that. Just your quintessential local watering hole and dive. No frills and the absolute perfect ambiance and vibe. Cold beer, affordable drinks and food (freshly prepared), and efficient service. Whether popping in by yourself for one or catching up with a group of friends while not wanting to go to an overly crowded bar, this is the spot. The real treat is when you are lucky to catch live music as well. Cash only so come prepared or hit the ATM inside.
Media Manley
The atmosphere is subjective and I love it here. You'll either love it or hate it.
It's old style Tavern built on old style traditional values. It's taking a walk back in time to the 40's. Former owner Russ built this place on the values he loved and instilled as part of his legacy. An Indy original!.
If you come here the burgers are the best. No frills just good hearty burgers.
Enjoy!
James Hall
Fantastic little bar. The vibe is totally unique to the area and anywhere I’ve been in Indy. Very limited menu which is perfectly fine. Potato salad and burger is where it’s at. Classic little no frills bar. Will definitely be back!
Aaron Book
Great dive bar. CASH ONLY. Had a great mix of patrons from young to old. Steve behind the bar was very friendly. Full bar with great beer selection. I got a Little King's. Not many places sell those at the bar.

Leave a Review

Do you guide private tours here? List your tour for free – no commission, travellers contact you directly.

List your tour for free
Explore More

Nearby Places

You may also like

Similar Places

Related Places