Busy, eco-minded coffeebar for espresso-based drinks, creative sandwiches & salads in snug digs.
At a glance
#54 of 70 Hamburger restaurants in New York #72 of 138 Sandwich shops in New YorkLocalGuideWorld score: 4.23
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★52%
-
4 ★26%
-
3 ★12%
-
2 ★5%
-
1 ★4%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Pickler Sandwich Shop?
- Pickler Sandwich Shop is rated 4.2 out of 5 based on 182 reviews.
- How does Pickler Sandwich Shop rank in New York?
- Pickler Sandwich Shop is #54 of 70 Hamburger restaurants in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Pickler Sandwich Shop located?
- 216 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017, United States — 1.1 km from the center of New York.
- How can I contact Pickler Sandwich Shop?
- Website: picklernyc.com
If you go to the shop to order they have 4 types of free pickle spears and you're allowed to select 2. If you order online it doesn't come with the free pickles. Their sandwiches are good but their fries are amazing. I got the prosciutto with fig jam on sourdough. Very unique flavors, it was on the sweeter side.
Was a little confused when we first walked in - (order on the right side of store at kiosk - receive from opposite) but food was prepared quickly and absolutely one of the most delicious sandwiches (turkey club) I've had. Doesn't come with a pickle, tho. Limited seating.
Reuben was fine but not overly memorable. No bathroom and the staff wasn’t interested in service, had to use machine while employee was busy on his phone. Very bizarre. There was no pickle provided.
Well I was eager to visit this place and really wanted to have a classic deli sandwich. I settled on a Reuben and man was I disappointed. Chaotic yet hip atmosphere kind of says take out only… though I sat there hoping to have a hot sandwich; unfortunately only the bread was warm, the rest cold, the Swiss cheese hard and the meat a fatty mess of bits… oh well.. maybe I’ll give it another try for it’s burger??
It really looked good in the pictures… maybe it was that I came at 11am too early… anyway too many other delis sandwich shops out there to out there to dwell on one…
It really looked good in the pictures… maybe it was that I came at 11am too early… anyway too many other delis sandwich shops out there to out there to dwell on one…
I got a Reuben sandwich and it’s so delicious.
The sauce is so tasty and the staff are very kind.
I recommend this restaurant!
The sauce is so tasty and the staff are very kind.
I recommend this restaurant!
Their prosciutto grilled cheese sandwich was too oily for me and the fig jam was overpowering so it tasted too sweet. The toast was a bit burnt. You can choose 2 pickles. I got their horseradish and spicy pickles which were good. They're also under construction right now so the menu options are limited.
One of my go-to sandwich places for workday lunches. Line gets long during peak lunch hour but never a long wait. I recently started ordering online for promos and mostly skipping lines. Personally not super into pickles but my colleague has only good things to say about them.
Nice little sandwich shop off 3rd Ave. with some great testing pressed sandwiches and fresh made burgers. You get to pick the type of pickle and coleslaw you want with your sandwich, beware they aren't kidding when they say spicy.
Seating is limited and it is right next to LIM college, so it can get a little crowded. The daily specials are some great deals!
Definitely worth a stop. The picture was my very tasty turkey club.
Seating is limited and it is right next to LIM college, so it can get a little crowded. The daily specials are some great deals!
Definitely worth a stop. The picture was my very tasty turkey club.
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
The Copy Room
View Place
Copycats
View Place
FedEx Authorized Ship Center
View Place
Castle Hill Capital Partners
View Place
JMC Holdings LLC
View Place
The Comfort Diner
View Place
Blank Financial Group
View Place
Legal Printing NYC
View Place
Permanent Mission of the Republic of Tajikistan to the United Nations
View Place
Consulate General of Nepal
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Mulberry Market NYC
View Place
BAPP Korean Restaurant (Kim's Corner Cafe)
View Place
Siam Orchid Thai Bistro
View Place
Claudia Sanders Dinner House
View Place
Open Market
View Place
Lima Coffee Shop
View Place
Eighty Eight Restaurant
View Place
Cheng Du Restaurant
View Place
India Taj Palace
View Place