Airy, exposed-brick space serving a variety of meatballs & sauces, with a full bar & live music.
At a glance
#16 of 18 Restaurants in Patchogue #3 of 3 Gastropubs in PatchogueLocalGuideWorld score: 4.01
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★51%
-
4 ★22%
-
3 ★12%
-
2 ★5%
-
1 ★10%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of That Meetball Place?
- That Meetball Place is rated 4.0 out of 5 based on 1,206 reviews.
- How does That Meetball Place rank in Patchogue?
- That Meetball Place is #16 of 18 Restaurants in Patchogue by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is That Meetball Place located?
- 54 W Main St, Patchogue, NY 11772, United States — 0.1 km from the center of Patchogue.
- How can I contact That Meetball Place?
- Phone: +1 631-569-5888 · Website: thatmeetballplaceli.com
Food is epic, beyond creative with a flair of taste that makes you realize your go-tos before this place were lame. Service is on point, Gaby was very attentive and offered amazing suggestions. Looking forward to coming back as there's so much more we need to try but unfortunately couldn't fit it all on our table this time.
P.s bottomless mimosa and bloodymarys with a seriously delish meatball on top, like 😲
P.s bottomless mimosa and bloodymarys with a seriously delish meatball on top, like 😲
We've seen this place for awhile now at multiple locations and wanted to give it a try. After trying it I'm not sure how it's been in business this long. The pretzel was good and the service was okay. The meatballs though...those things that the place is named after...yikes. not sure if they were undercooked or if there were too many breadcrumbs used but the middle was soggy and mushy, almost pasty. The portions were laughable and the flavors were just boring. My wife got the Buffalo one which she barely ate and I got the original which was just sad. Will not be back, there are plenty of places that make meatballs and sauce better than here.
I planned a bachelor party in Long Island and we stopped here for lunch. The food and service was great. Thomas Fazio made our experience there unforgettable for our bachelor. So memorable! Would definitely go again maybe during the evening when it turns into a late night spot!
Tried a sampler
(Are the meatballs supposed to be room temperature?)
And deviled eggs.
Teriyaki Meetball was the only good thing I had.
Not a fan of game meat and the middle meatball confirmed it.
The meatball to the left
The texture was just mushy . It fell apart as soon as you touch it .
Taste was not good.
Deviled eggs laid on a bed of blue cheese sauce topped with a piece of boneless buffalo chicken . Drenched In sauce.
Just horrible in my opinion
My friend enjoyed the food a little better than I so I have to be fair and give it a 4star.
Because I need to try other items on the menu.
Staff was nice.
(Are the meatballs supposed to be room temperature?)
And deviled eggs.
Teriyaki Meetball was the only good thing I had.
Not a fan of game meat and the middle meatball confirmed it.
The meatball to the left
The texture was just mushy . It fell apart as soon as you touch it .
Taste was not good.
Deviled eggs laid on a bed of blue cheese sauce topped with a piece of boneless buffalo chicken . Drenched In sauce.
Just horrible in my opinion
My friend enjoyed the food a little better than I so I have to be fair and give it a 4star.
Because I need to try other items on the menu.
Staff was nice.
Went for the monthly drag bingo show. It was fine but I kept comparing it to the amazing Bitchy Bingo they used to have at LIPS NYC, which isn't fair. But as far as drag on the Eastern end of LI, I guess this is the only game in town. I don't know if their mouths were too close to the microphone but it was hard to understand them. Also, they had two shows, so go to the second...I felt like we were racing through the bingo games at break-neck speed to get us out so the 2nd show could start on time. The tall queen wasn't friendly and they constantly walked around with giant laundry baskets for customers to put money in. Seemed like a giant two-hour money grab. I won't be back.
Surprisingly great place for Sunday brunch, good food, and of course, Bottomless Mimosas. But this is a great place to come anytime breakfast, lunch or dinner. And if you want a drink they definitely have you covered.
A fun, friendly bar restaurant. Good food. Fast service. Reasonably priced. Live music some nights. A great local hang out. We went late on a Saturday night and there was a lot of tables available but it started to get crowded as we left for late night drinks at the bar. Nice atmosphere. Assorted items on menu including non-meat entrees. Check it out
This place is great. Checkout their monthly Vegan Night with the Long Island Herbivore. Really great vegan tasting menu with an open bar. The menu changes every month. I'm not even vegan and I loved it!
The regular menu is great too and I originally reviewed 5 stars 6 years ago for their fun going out nights on the weekends with DJs and live music.
The regular menu is great too and I originally reviewed 5 stars 6 years ago for their fun going out nights on the weekends with DJs and live music.
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Chops Steakhouse
View Place
Dirty Taco + Tequila Patchogue
View Place
The State Room
View Place
Del Fuego
View Place
Stereo Banquets
View Place
Stereo Garden
View Place
The Cuban
View Place
Burgerology Patchogue
View Place
Locale Gastro Bar and Pizzette
View Place
Virgola
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
The Gin Mill
View Place
Red Restaurant and Bar
View Place
New Mexico Hard Cider Taproom
View Place
Due West
View Place
The Folly
View Place
Yard House
View Place
Finback Alehouse
View Place
Seven Lakes Station
View Place
Yard House
View Place