LocalGuideWorld – Best Places to Visit, Eat & Stay Around the World

At a glance

#4 of 4 Italian restaurants in Sag Harbor

LocalGuideWorld score: 4.21

0.0 km from the center of Sag Harbor

Rating breakdown

  • 5 ★63%
  • 4 ★14%
  • 3 ★8%
  • 2 ★5%
  • 1 ★10%
16 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 1
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 2
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 3
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 4
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 5
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 6
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 7
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 8
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 9
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 10
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 11
Tutto il Giorno Sag, Sag Harbor – photo 12

Quick facts

What is the rating of Tutto il Giorno Sag?
Tutto il Giorno Sag is rated 4.2 out of 5 based on 278 reviews.
How does Tutto il Giorno Sag rank in Sag Harbor?
Tutto il Giorno Sag is #4 of 4 Italian restaurants in Sag Harbor by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
Where is Tutto il Giorno Sag located?
16 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 — 0.0 km from the center of Sag Harbor.
How can I contact Tutto il Giorno Sag?
Phone: (631) 919-5353 · Website: tuttoilgiorno.com
Rosario S. Cassata (Batman)
Great Italian Restaurant in Sag Harbor.. Tutto il Giorno offers indoor and outdoor dining. The restaurant has a nautical theme. and a boutique. We have been here several times and it doesn't disappoint.
Jack Clayton
I ate here for lunch and was not a huge fan of their food. However, the place was nice and the staff were AMAZING, which is why i added an extra star.

The food though.. is a diff story. I got the tuna tartare and that was not very good. Got the spaghetti as well and that wasnt the best either. It didnt have any meat on it… for $30…? Come onnn
John Pitts
Beautiful room, beautiful self-intoxicated people. The food, when it eventually arrived, was merely decent…if it had no hair in it. The terrible, inattentive, incompetent service sealed the deal. Clearly it wasn’t for lack of help. The place was crawling with staff. The poor fellow who seemed to be our waiter was apologetic by the end of our ordeal, which suggests to me that they have a management problem. The check, of course, did not reflect the poor quality of the evening.
Winder Perez
Yesterday I had the unfortunate experience of dining at Tutto and I must say that it was one of the most disappointing dining experiences I've ever had. Not only was the wait excessively long. Even though I had a reservation, but the behavior of the manager left a bitter taste in my mouth.

Upon arriving at the restaurant, I was informed of that they were running a bit behind. While I understand that busy establishments can have delays, an hour-long wait seemed excessive and poorly managed. The lack of effective communication and organization made the wait feel even longer and more frustrating.

To make matters worse, the manager's attitude towards the situation was nothing short of rude and dismissive. When approached for an update or to express our concerns, the manager Jen displayed an utter lack of empathy and professionalism. Instead of addressing our valid concerns, we were met with condescending remarks( “sorry I don’t know how I would feel if I was in your shoes because I’m not” and “sorry that you feel that way”) and an overall apathetic demeanor. This behavior only exacerbated the frustration and disappointment we felt.

When we finally got seated, the overall dining experience failed to compensate for the arduous wait. The quality of the food was average at best, and the service lacked the attentiveness and warmth one would expect. It was evident that the staff, likely influenced by the manager's behavior, were disengaged and disinterested in providing a memorable dining experience.

A long wait can be forgivable if the restaurant makes efforts to rectify the situation and deliver exceptional service. However, the combination of an hour-long wait and a rude manager creates an atmosphere of discomfort and dissatisfaction. It is disheartening when a restaurant of this caliber fails to value its customers and prioritize their experience, especially when they invest their time and money into dining there.

I cannot recommend this restaurant to anyone based on my experience. The excessive wait time coupled with the unprofessional behavior of the manager resulted in an unpleasant dining experience. I hope that Jen is able to find these notes “productive” ( one of her responses while I tried to voice my concerns, where that the conversation was unproductive) enough to makes the necessary improvements to ensure a more enjoyable experience for future patrons.
Sasha Rahmati
We apparently made the mistake of trying to have dinner here on Saturday at 5 pm without a reservation.. which is totally fine. It was the rudeness and condescending attitude of the host that made this a 1 star. He recommended that none of the nicer restaurants in town would have room and that we should try the more casual restaurants in town. Thankfully we called another fancy Italian restaurant in town and they had room for us. Had he have been nice and suggested us another reservation for another day or not tried to educate us on nice restaurants not having room, I wouldn’t have cared. That guy needs to get out of the service industry.
Gina
My favorite restaurant in all of the Hamptons. Excellent restaurant all around. The food is incredible especially the spaghetti “scarpariello”. Wine is terrific and the ambiance is romantic and homey at the same time. Highly recommend. And it’s open all year round for us locals.
J Marchese
Probably one of the prettiest restaurants in the Hamptons. With a gorgeous patio and indoor space, decorated in a stunning beach chic decor, this is the place to see and be seen in the Hamptons.
The food is great “most” of the time (recently I had a butternut squash soup for my appetizer that was tasteless), and some of the dishes can blend at times. During the high season, you cannot get a table without a reservation, so plan to wait over 2 hours if you do a walk-in (sometimes they won’t even be able to accommodate you). The menu prices are true to Hampton prices, so don’t be shocked to pay over $30 for a glass of wine, and upwards of $130 for the most inexpensive bottle. The last few times we were there, we felt cheated (the check was outrageously expensive and the food wasn’t that great).
Ameya Bhakay
We were in Sag Harbor on a moderately cold March afternoon and walked by this place which was yet to open at around 3 pm. After getting a drink from a near by bar, we showed up again at 3:45 and their team was kind enough to get seating in a wonderfully setup outdoor area.

They noticed we were all cold, and so was our 2 year old, and their super helpful and friendly staff put 4 outdoor heaters in 4 corners for us so we could enjoy our time here. And what a fabulous experience we had. Their entire team is absolutely amazing and they mixed some powerful and tasty cocktails for our group.

We had just come back from lunch, so weren't that hungry, but everytime we passed the kitchen the aroma from food was just making us a but hungry which made us order their Risotto ($35) and Tortelli ($34) which our server suggested.

Now, in my opinion, Indian's are the biggest critiques of Italian food and often times find it bland, thanks to our "sometimes" overpowering, yet flavorful spices, so the expectation was quite low - but were we surprised when presented with one of the most flavorful and delicious Italian food we've ever had!

We were running late for a dinner reservation, which we couldn't cancel at the last minute, else this was an absolute perfect place to wine and dine! This place is bookmarked as one of our favorites and special thanks to the super friendly team at Tutto for a wonderful evening filled with excellent ambiance, food, and service.

Will definitely visit again!

Leave a Review

Do you guide private tours here? List your tour for free – no commission, travellers contact you directly.

List your tour for free
Explore More

Nearby Places

You may also like

Similar Places

Related Places