Amish Market East, New York: Photos, Reviews & Location

Branch of a local chain of grocers offering fruits, vegetables, meat, cheese & prepared foods to-go.

At a glance

#1 of 6 Buffet restaurants in New York #45 of 124 Pizza restaurants in New York

LocalGuideWorld score: 4.39

0.4 km from the center of New York

Rating breakdown

5 ★64%
4 ★23%
3 ★8%
2 ★2%
1 ★3%

240 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017, United States

eastamish45.com

+1 212-370-1761

Photos of Amish Market East (54)

View all

Quick facts

What is the rating of Amish Market East?: Amish Market East is rated 4.4 out of 5 based on 677 reviews.
How does Amish Market East rank in New York?: Amish Market East is #1 of 6 Buffet restaurants in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
Where is Amish Market East located?: 240 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017, United States — 0.4 km from the center of New York.
How can I contact Amish Market East?: Phone: +1 212-370-1761 · Website: eastamish45.com

Reviews (8)

monicaa 2023 Oct 10

Best specialty grocery store in the area! Always has a large variety of snacks. They serve fresh hot lunch buffet that is equally affordable and delicious. Always come here to satisfy my sweets craving.

Olga Berestetskaya 2023 Sep 28

Never knew city had an Amish Market, so it was a nice surprise. It seemed to have everything and good selection of interesting cheese.

Jim Paterson 2023 Aug 04

I really appreciated this Deli. In a baking hot New York summer, the salad bar is just brilliant, providing a refreshing, filling, healthy and tasty lunch. Their salads offer a welcome respite to New York's excruciatingly high prices. They also have a pizza oven and self-service buffet arrangement too, amidst wall to wall adornments of fresh fruit and veg, cured meats and seafood, lots of cheeses, breads, delicacies, deserts, chocolates and more. In fact, the shop is crammed full of delicacies, with every available space used to ensure their offering of an extensive variety of stock. Amish market is a brand name, and this is actually a chain store deli.

audrey 2023 May 16

C'est mon magasin préféré du quartier de hell's kitchen en tant que touriste vous êtes toujours très bien accueilli.
Cher mais comme partout à New York.
Le nombre de produits est assez incroyable.
Nous avons ramené des sauces pour faire des barbecue en France. Elles sont excellentes !
Je vous conseille de salade de fruits qui sont excellentes et vous permettront de manger sainement.

Adaiah Paul 2023 May 12

It has so much yummy stuff

Lucian Gem (M Fontenelle) 2023 Mar 31

Didn't know what to expect but it wasn't this variety of modern products that seemed too much for the small space.
The fresh lunch options were tasty and priced for the location. As were the desserts. Thankfully, the coffee was hot and well-made, as the constantly opening door made for a cold lunch in March. Staff were neutral

D K 2022 Nov 22

Has been a welcome addition to the neighborhood since its arrival. Their sandwiches menu is varied and large and the sandwiches are very good. In the hot summer months the gazpacho and cucumber yogurt soups rock. The hot prepared buffet is very good and also very varied with a catered meal quality. The fresh made brick oven pizza are a find. The grocery selection, especially the olive oils, vinegars and cheese, provides a wide assortment and a decent value. The other grocery items are broad as well but varying in price. The produce and vegetable selection is better than the local "chain" supermarkets and is usually well priced in comparison as well. The butcher shop has great meats and poultry. There’s a small selection of fresh fish as well as frozen.

Simon Butler 2019 Aug 30

Fantastic grocery store that stocks pretty much everything you need. It's very vegan friendly as they stock vegan wraps, snacks, tofu, hummus, amazing fruit and veg, plant milks, vegan dairy products etc,. But it also has a great meat counter, cured meats, dairy etc too. Only downside is NYC prices but this isn't their fault.