LocalGuideWorld – Best Places to Visit, Eat & Stay Around the World
Health-conscious cafe offering build-your-own salads, wraps & other light bites in compact quarters.

At a glance

Rating breakdown

  • 5 ★58%
  • 4 ★24%
  • 3 ★4%
  • 2 ★6%
  • 1 ★8%
24-20 Jackson Ave, Long Island City, NY 11101
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 1
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 2
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 3
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 4
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 5
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 6
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 7
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 8
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 9
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 10
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 11
Pantry Market Eatery, Long Island City – photo 12

Quick facts

What is the rating of Pantry Market Eatery?
Pantry Market Eatery is rated 4.2 out of 5 based on 263 reviews.
Where is Pantry Market Eatery located?
24-20 Jackson Ave, Long Island City, NY 11101
How can I contact Pantry Market Eatery?
Phone: (718) 606-2299 · Website: pantryeatery.com
Adam Fredman
Because this store near to my office I stop by to take my lunch and was bad experience really
Very nasty service,rude girl behind counter she should learn how to speak with customers I don’t know how owner hire this kind of staff . I just ask her if my order ready because I’m waiting 25 minutes and store almost empty she said wait wait
Wow . After all I find my self with fishy food I just
Toss in trash and never back again .
Tasnim Rahman
I ordered delivery from here and I was really pleasantly surprised at the quality and portion size. This is going to be a long review because I couldn't suss out from the previous reviews if it was legit and I have some time to kill.

I ordered the og acai bowl for $13. It's the first great acai bowl I've gotten in the area. It was vibrantly purple, with an even layer of granola, and lots of perfectly ripe blueberries, strawberries, and bananas. The acai base filled up most of the bowl and was very cold. I live about 10m away, and I was worried about the heat melting it since it's so hot right now. If you live farther, it could probably stretch about 10 more minutes for delivery.

Also ordered the southwest steak panini. It was $14. It was a hefty, warm sandwich. The filling tasted more like a breakfast hash than I expected, but my partner wasn't mad about it. I would probably only be able to eat half of it for lunch, with a yogurt on the side.

Last but not least, I ordered the chicken caesar wrap ($14). I haven't gotten a chance to eat it yet, but it looks substantially full. I could probably eat it for lunch with a small snack.

I gave it 5 stars because this is everything I want from a healthy, american cuisine lunch spot. It's quick, satisfying, tasty, and appropriately priced.
HL Lai
As a local who frequents the area, I used to order breakfast and lunch from this delightful spot quite often. The staff has always been extremely attentive and friendly, creating a warm atmosphere. Their salads have consistently been fresh and enjoyable.

However, over time, I've observed a decline in both the quality and quantity of the food, which has led to less frequent visits. Despite these changes, I continue to appreciate this establishment and hope they can regain their consistency in quality. I look forward to returning in a few months to see if any positive improvements have been made.
Araba Waters
Great place for fresh delicious and healthy lunch options!! Food was fresh made and a very nice portion. The also have a small eating area inside and outside.
Anthony M
Very nice and calm place to grab lunch. The grilled chicken pesto panini was very filling and fresh. Can't do much better for the price point. Staff is very curtious and respectful.
Andrea Francis
Been here a number of times and usually order the Garden Panini. The first time, a few months ago, when the ingredients didn't match what was listed on the menu and therefore what I was paying for, I let it slide. Today, it happened again - I'm ordering a vegetarian sandwich that features eggplant and grilled portobello as the main ingredients but instead I'm given what I assume was the roast vegetable side for whatever was the main meal of the day. The sandwich consisted of grilled zucchini, what appeared to be summer squash, a few pieces of bell pepper, and a large portion of roast onion.

I understand buying seasonal as it's tastier and cheaper, but then 'seasonal vegetables' should be what is listed and the price adjusted accordingly. Zucchini is featured in the ingredient list, of course, but zucchini and portobello mushrooms are not at the same price point, so I paid for food I never received. Further, as an allergy mom it's scary to think that an establishment can be so blasé about their offering not resembling their ingredient list. They did manage to put a tiny bit of the Swiss cheese listed on the ingredients into the sandwich, but it was so little as to render it almost impercetible. When I'm paying $12 for a sandwich, it would be great if the ingredients that give the sandwich its heft actually appear in it. My only regret was that I chose to eat at my desk so could not speak with the staff on site.

Additionally, I find it deeply problematic that we are being charged the merchant fee for swiping a credit card at this establishment. Either treat the fee as a part of the cost of your doing business, which it is, or put up a large sign by the machine to say customers are expected to pay the fee, so people can choose to pay in cash. I wouldn't have known about the fee if I hadn't studied the screen because the employee would not listen to me when I said that the screen was not progressing and asked what I needed to do - she just kept saying 'it went through' but I had not reached the point where I could click 'Pay now'. I was forced to hit the cancel button because it seemed that she expected me to walk away from a screen where my credit card was still live and it seemed I actually hadn't paid! Needless to say, she wasn't impressed about having to ring up the order again.

I'm sad to even write this review as I want to support local businesses and I remember when this space was still Sage General Store and I would frequent it as well, but today's experience, coupled with the prior sandwich dupe which in retrospect was likely not an error, has left much wanting.
Thomas Overmiller
The inside dining area is cramped but nicely decorated. The "real moss" wall is a really nice touch! The service is friendly and reasonable fast and the drink options are well-chosen. I enjoyed the Kentucky BBQ burger burger🍔, done medium. It was fantastic! My only "beef" 😊 is that the bread 🍞 was soggy and difficult to handle. The price was a bit high $10 for a burger, otherwise a great experience overall.
Howard
Nice additional coffee and food option to the expanding LIC neighbourhood. The inside has a rustic feel with exposed pipes and grain wood walls, but is also clean and modern. The food options are great; avocado toast is a regular favourite. The coffee is on the pricey side but is strong and good quality.
There’s limited seating (one long bench and some window seats) so take out is the usual choice.

Leave a Review

Do you guide private tours here? List your tour for free – no commission, travellers contact you directly.

List your tour for free
Explore More

Nearby Places

You may also like

Similar Places

Related Places