A bright spot offering sandwiches, homemade ice cream, coffee and fresh juice in modern digs.
At a glance
#22 of 32 Coffee shops in New Orleans #11 of 13 Sandwich shops in New OrleansLocalGuideWorld score: 4.50
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★79%
-
4 ★9%
-
3 ★4%
-
2 ★3%
-
1 ★5%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Fat Boy Pantry?
- Fat Boy Pantry is rated 4.5 out of 5 based on 564 reviews.
- How does Fat Boy Pantry rank in New Orleans?
- Fat Boy Pantry is #22 of 32 Coffee shops in New Orleans by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Fat Boy Pantry located?
- 1302 Magazine St, New Orleans, LA 70130 — 1.3 km from the center of New Orleans.
- How can I contact Fat Boy Pantry?
- Phone: (504) 239-9514 · Website: fatboypantry.com
I came to this place with the hopes of eating a good lobster po-boy, but instead me and my brother was stereotyped over a 3 dollar root beer!!! They needed to verify that we pay for it after paying 47$ including a root beer and 31$ for my sandwich alone. We provided the receipt on the simple fact that we just paid almost a 100$ for just two sandwiches. I will not be coming back and if you black you should consider going else where based on how we were treated.
Hands down - amazing! We had the lobster Po'Boy and fries and it did not disappoint. The bread was soft and buttery, the lobster was large, tender pieces that were battered and fried and there wasn't an ungodly amount of sauce or extra stuff to take away from the flavor of the lobster. The fries were hand+cut and perfectly seasoned. We added some Creole seasoning to the ketchup before dipping but otherwise they were perfection. We attempted to walk from our hotel to grab food but at 11 p.m. the area was a tad sketch so we drove the 4 blocks to get there but It was totally worth walking, driving, flying, etc.
The bad: fries were ok, needed salt
The good: I had the Havana. At first I thought I was robbed and simply pressed some basic deli meat. Then I took a bite! Goodness of flavor and spice creating a mouthful of adventure. Price is slightly higher then I’d like but their Havana is one of the tops in Nola.
The good: I had the Havana. At first I thought I was robbed and simply pressed some basic deli meat. Then I took a bite! Goodness of flavor and spice creating a mouthful of adventure. Price is slightly higher then I’d like but their Havana is one of the tops in Nola.
The lobster rolls were really good. However, the atmosphere and the service wasn’t. We paid over $30 for each lobster roll and had to sit at a table with all of this clutter on the table. There are other restaurants nearby that serve the same quality lobster rolls and provide waiters to bring us our drinks etc. This restaurant is self served and expensive. Plus the seating arrangements are not good for families with little kids.
NO SEASONING. We got the pantry burger and fries, which looked so good and fresh but could not eat more than one bite. There was no seasoning on the fries- not even salt. The burger was a hunk of meat with zero flavor or seasoning and the bacon was a thick slab of barely cooked pork...a complete waste of a walk and $35.
First visit, got the Philly Cheese on recommendation of owner...right on point, hot, messy, and delicious...including fresh cut fries.
Told the "indoor seating is not available due to a large party coming soon..." I must say the outdoor seating is a 1 STAR, right on Magazine with speeding cars, way to close! The ditch is disgusting and stinks, but that's most of NOLA anyway...so no one came to sit inside the whole time I was there...if you can't eat inside I'd recommendation take away only.
Told the "indoor seating is not available due to a large party coming soon..." I must say the outdoor seating is a 1 STAR, right on Magazine with speeding cars, way to close! The ditch is disgusting and stinks, but that's most of NOLA anyway...so no one came to sit inside the whole time I was there...if you can't eat inside I'd recommendation take away only.
This place is awesome. Hands down the best lobster possible boy I have ever had. The ice cream is amazing. You can tell that it is home made.
This is a must try in NOLA. I am going to become a regular.
This is a must try in NOLA. I am going to become a regular.
Awesome little eatery, very easy walk from WW2 or Ogden Museum, appx 4 blocks. Everything is made in house, portions are generous and flavors are amazing. We heard many great reviews mentioning everything from their coffee / espresso, breakfasts and sandwiches to their store made ice creams featuring local flavors and produce. The variety is impressive from Benedicts, to Burgers, Gyros and Lobster too.
Do yourself and your taste buds a favor, stop by and try their food - maybe you'll make multiple visits during your time in NOLA like we did. If you can, be sure to chat with the friendly owner Dan & his crew !!
Do yourself and your taste buds a favor, stop by and try their food - maybe you'll make multiple visits during your time in NOLA like we did. If you can, be sure to chat with the friendly owner Dan & his crew !!
Leave a Review
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
CrossFit NOLA Downtown
View Place
Barrel Proof
View Place
French Truck Coffee
View Place
Escape My Room New Orleans
View Place
Lafon Fountain
View Place
Margaret Place Park
View Place
Bakery Bar
View Place
New Orleans Ballet Theatre
View Place
Margaret Haughery Statue
View Place
Fleur De Lis Mansion Bed and Breakfast
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Tarallucci e Vino Upper West Side
View Place
Alif Cafe
View Place
McDonald's
View Place
McDonald's
View Place
Book Club
View Place
Old Soul Donut Company
View Place
Japan Village
View Place
Café Du Monde Mail Order
View Place
Coffee ME Up
View Place