Snug neighborhood counter-serve turning out square & round pizza by the slice or pie.
At a glance
#105 of 254 Italian restaurants in New York #36 of 124 Pizza restaurants in New YorkLocalGuideWorld score: 4.40
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★72%
-
4 ★14%
-
3 ★6%
-
2 ★3%
-
1 ★5%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Village Square Pizza?
- Village Square Pizza is rated 4.4 out of 5 based on 1,076 reviews.
- How does Village Square Pizza rank in New York?
- Village Square Pizza is #105 of 254 Italian restaurants in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Village Square Pizza located?
- 147 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009, United States — 2.8 km from the center of New York.
- How can I contact Village Square Pizza?
- Phone: +1 917-675-7709 · Website: villagesquarepizzanyc.com
Super tasty 😋 pizza 🍕 slice I got from the pizza store. Square but unique. 🤩 Tried the vodka type and amazed me how fluffy and delicious 🤤 it is.
Quality pizza at a very good price point! Very affordable as an alternative to all of the foo foo restaurants in the area. Happy counter help, always fresh pizza and always good! I come here often for a quick snack. Be sure to stop by when you’re in the area.
I came during lunch and was expecting a long line, but I was actually the only one in there. I ordered the pepperoni pizza with hot honey. This pizza had a good/crunchy crust but was also soft. They also aren't shy with the pepperonis.
Pizza is really good. Like REALLY good. I ate these 3 slices and the vodka was great and crispy and creamy. The meat lover one was not greasy somehow, and it had amazing spices and flavors from the sausage and the pepperoni. Was honestly the best one and the buffalo chicken one had the right amount of kick and was. Another great slice. Worth it. Crispy bottoms, no floppy sloppy droopy pizza and great flavor.
Loved the use of the cupping pepperoni which were nice and crispy, but what really stood out to me was just how delicious the dough and bread was on the pizza! Very flavorful and has this amazing crunch to it.
A hole in the wall pizza shop with great pizza. Yes just go try it. After I ordered, I saw the articles posted on the wall about the popular pepperoni slice but I got others. The display shows mostly square slices - if you want a round slice they are behind the counter. STANDING room only.
One of the hardest things I ever had to do was break up with East Village Pizza. I'll spare you the novel, but I couldn't justify paying $6.25 for a single slice of thin crust pepperoni pizza that would just wake my stomach up and leave me hungrier than before.
After taking a few months to heal, I was finally ready to get back on the horse and find a new late night pizza spot to hit after striking out at the local bars.
On Saturday, after striking out at the local bars, my buddy mentioned this place and that it was a good Prince Street Pizza comparable. We walked in here and were met with a small line and not one, but two, neon signs. I love a good neon sign.
The staff is LOCKED in and are running this thing like a finely tuned machine. I opted to get two slices of the thick square pizza, with the cute little slightly charred pepperonis on top hehe. $11.98 total for two thick slices. HUGE.
I think this may be better than Prince Street, but if it's not, it's 1a/1b. The crust is perfectly crisped, and those pepperonis are a gift from god. True artistry.
After demolishing the first slice, I was like "Damn I lowkey could have been good with just one slice..." I think I am still a bit scarred from the East Village Pizza relationship.
I have found my new late night pizza spot. I want to leave you, my dear reader, with a quote from Marilyn Monroe:
"Sometimes good things fall apart so better things can fall together."
IG @jnov_
Tiktok @jnov__
After taking a few months to heal, I was finally ready to get back on the horse and find a new late night pizza spot to hit after striking out at the local bars.
On Saturday, after striking out at the local bars, my buddy mentioned this place and that it was a good Prince Street Pizza comparable. We walked in here and were met with a small line and not one, but two, neon signs. I love a good neon sign.
The staff is LOCKED in and are running this thing like a finely tuned machine. I opted to get two slices of the thick square pizza, with the cute little slightly charred pepperonis on top hehe. $11.98 total for two thick slices. HUGE.
I think this may be better than Prince Street, but if it's not, it's 1a/1b. The crust is perfectly crisped, and those pepperonis are a gift from god. True artistry.
After demolishing the first slice, I was like "Damn I lowkey could have been good with just one slice..." I think I am still a bit scarred from the East Village Pizza relationship.
I have found my new late night pizza spot. I want to leave you, my dear reader, with a quote from Marilyn Monroe:
"Sometimes good things fall apart so better things can fall together."
IG @jnov_
Tiktok @jnov__
One of the best sicilian style pizza I have had! The sauce is so flavored along with a perfectly crunchy base. The pizza is not too at all greasy or oily. They have variety of veggie and non vegetarian options to choose from.
You can stand inside along the narrow counter to eat. The service was quick!
You can stand inside along the narrow counter to eat. The service was quick!
Enjoyed a delicious slice of original New York-style pizza at Village Square Pizza. The pizza was tasty, unique, and the service was commendable. A great place for pizza lovers – definitely recommended. Solid 4 stars.
A must every time we visit. The pepperoni is always a great treat. Kid at the register was straight out of it. Did not have a convoy of service. Slices were great!!!
Unfortunately, their pizza certainly doesn't taste as good as it looks. We tried a slice of Grandma's, which was under-seasoned with little excitement in the crust and the pepperoni/sausage pizza, which unfortunately was SO drenched in hot honey, we couldn't taste anything but sauce. Shame because we've heard great things about this store, but it just doesn't seem to measure up against the other NY pizza classics.
An amazing thick crust that has a good flavor, is crisp yet chewy, for both the square and round slices. They have 2 vegan options, average price per slice is $5 and a great tomato sauce.
My only criticism was the amount of sauce in the pepperoni slice we got. Given a thicker square crust, I would have liked to see a bit more sauce to have made it more enjoyable.
The vegan eggplant square and plain cheese slice were good too.
My only criticism was the amount of sauce in the pepperoni slice we got. Given a thicker square crust, I would have liked to see a bit more sauce to have made it more enjoyable.
The vegan eggplant square and plain cheese slice were good too.
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Blank Street Coffee
View Place
Social Tees Animal Rescue Office
View Place
Poke and Roll Sushi
View Place
141 Avenue A Associates
View Place
Tompkins Square Park Skate Park
View Place
TabeTomo
View Place
Amerinda Inc
View Place
Ten Degrees
View Place
Hanoi House
View Place
11th Street Community Garden
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Tarallucci e Vino Upper West Side
View Place
Officina at The Wharf
View Place
TESSA
View Place
Osteria Cotta
View Place
Lucciola
View Place
Trattoria iL Gusto Wine Bar
View Place
Bella Luna Restaurant
View Place
Bosphorus Restaurant
View Place
Sorrento's Pizza House
View Place