LocalGuideWorld – Best Places to Visit, Eat & Stay Around the World

At a glance

#5 of 5 Delis in Staten Island #11 of 15 Bagel shops in Staten Island

LocalGuideWorld score: 4.12

0.9 km from the center of Staten Island

Rating breakdown

  • 5 ★58%
  • 4 ★19%
  • 3 ★8%
  • 2 ★5%
  • 1 ★10%
5840 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309
The Bagel Box, Staten Island – photo 1

Quick facts

What is the rating of The Bagel Box?
The Bagel Box is rated 4.1 out of 5 based on 197 reviews.
How does The Bagel Box rank in Staten Island?
The Bagel Box is #5 of 5 Delis in Staten Island by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
Where is The Bagel Box located?
5840 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309 — 0.9 km from the center of Staten Island.
How can I contact The Bagel Box?
Phone: (718) 966-6097 · Website: thebagelboxsi.com
Daniel McCarthy
New ownership has really changed and renovated entire store and menu the bagels are delicious. Kudos to the new owner for changing the once seedy environment.
Matt Nichols
Best bagels on Staten Island. The new owner has turned this location into a top notch deli with a ton of awesome selections for breakfast and lunch.
Sarah Tofilska
I had my sister pick up some plain bagels, and I was definitely disappointed when I opened the bag. These bagels are not what they used to be. They used to be perfectly baked New York style bagels, but the ones I got today looked like they came from my local grocery store. The old ones used to be so fluffy and delicious, I don’t know what happened. The ones today were far from real New York bagels. I miss the old plump bagels.
Natalie Tytman
Don’t listen to the bad reviews I’ve come here dozens of times and it’s always been great. New owner made it even better. The place runs more efficiently now. I’m going there later actually 😂
darin rivera
I was there at night. Asked the merchant what bagels are the freshest he said all of them were. That was not the case . When I got home my wife went to have a bagel and it was hard like a rock 🪨won't buy bagels there any more but they make great sandwiches as long it's not on bagels
D D
Just left the Bagel Box place. I frequent and order from at least three times a week. Sometimes four I will never be going back there. The audacity to charge $19.75 for two bagels with cream cheese and bacon and two seltzers! You also lost a pizza customer at Domenicos as well. If I can give this zero stars I would, but Google doesn’t allow it. You earned it!!!
Xavier Rogers
Only been here a few times but they got solid bagels, always get the cream cheese and lox and its about 8-9 bucks if i remember right, which is about what it is everywhere else too. there was a decent amount of lox on the bagel, I've had far less put on at other places. Bagel was pretty soft and tasted fresh, and i had it my hands within about a minute of ordering so very fast service. Better value to just buy a pack of lox at the supermarket and put it on yourself
Chris Romano
First time leaving a negative review anywhere. This is for Bagel Box, not Seguine Bagels, which is the ghost kitchen inside of S.B. for delivery. Ordered a hero, but when it gets late, heros are normally sold out, so I said if that's the case, a roll is fine (which costs less), but to replace the price difference with something I put in the order notes, but it wasn't there when delivered. It happened last time too, but that time, the (owner I think) actually made it right. Maybe tonight it was someone else, following the typical "order is out the door, so - out of sight, out of mind, I still get paid the same" mindset.
Very disappointing when I usually have a generally positive food ordering/delivery 'experience' (or whatever you want to call it.)

Leave a Review

Do you guide private tours here? List your tour for free – no commission, travellers contact you directly.

List your tour for free
Explore More

Nearby Places

You may also like

Similar Places

Related Places