LocalGuideWorld – Best Places to Visit, Eat & Stay Around the World
Compact, unpretentious restaurant delivering a diverse menu of Mexican classics, plus wine & beer.

At a glance

#31 of 96 Mexican restaurants in New York

LocalGuideWorld score: 4.40

6.1 km from the center of New York

Rating breakdown

  • 5 ★66%
  • 4 ★20%
  • 3 ★5%
  • 2 ★4%
  • 1 ★5%
69 New St, New York, NY 10004, United States
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 1
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 2
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 3
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 4
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 5
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 6
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 7
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 8
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 9
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 10
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 11
El Toro mexican grill, New York – photo 12

Quick facts

What is the rating of El Toro mexican grill?
El Toro mexican grill is rated 4.4 out of 5 based on 271 reviews.
How does El Toro mexican grill rank in New York?
El Toro mexican grill is #31 of 96 Mexican restaurants in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
Where is El Toro mexican grill located?
69 New St, New York, NY 10004, United States — 6.1 km from the center of New York.
How can I contact El Toro mexican grill?
Phone: +1 212-363-3900 · Website: eltoronyc.com
Katelyn McCarey
Amazing Service. Even Better Food and Marge. 12/10. Highly recommend!!
Alexa Castillo
Wonderful!!! Was visiting the city from New Jersey, I came in with a party of 6 The owner politely acknowledged us immediately, and got our drinks , we ordered our food and was served in a Timely manner everything was absolutely delicious! If you have never been here I 100% recommended!!! Will definitely be returning!! ❤️❤️
Julian Zobel
Ist etwas unscheinbar und abseits gelegen, aber die Preise sind für die sehr großen Portionen vollkommen in Ordnung und das Essen hat wirklich sehr lecker geschmeckt! Hier würde ich wieder hingehen, das Tagesmenü war wirklich gut! Man bekommt leider, wie so oft in den USA, nur Plastikbesteck.
Christine
Went here with my friend for a bite and honestly it was very good. The waitress was sweet and helpful. The food was delicious and honestly good for its price too.
Hayden C
Excellent food choices and delicious, seats are also available but it's limited.

Cocktails are delicious, I would recommend the mango margarita. They also have a decent level of alcohol too.

I would highly recommend the chicken mole, it was flavourful and portion size was very good. Staff members are very friendly and give you recommendations too and make good and strong cocktails.

However what I disliked about the place is they were charging extra money almost $10 extra (perhaps it was percentage based) to use card instead of cash. I could not see this displayed anywhere nor did our server tell us this before we ordered, they also added a mandatory service charge of 18%, this is my first time in New York and most places made it optional and we were happy to give that in cash and pay the full bill in card. Just keep that in mind as you walk into this restaurant.
Gastrophilist
Shrimp Enchiladas were listed to come with rice and beans but only received rice that was very different than flavorful Mexican rice. The rice seemed stale and mixed with some tomatoey sauce. Shrimp enchilada is just as described, there’s only cooked shrimp inside the tortilla. There’s no other seasoning or veggies mixed in there. I don’t think the enchilada sauce is restaurant made, it tastes way to tangy and processed like canned sauces. Overall, this was very disappointing and will not be going back anytime soon.
Maria Barrera
I recommend El Toro restaurant. Food is made to order - no reheated, premade stuff here. The mole enchiladas are superb - you can taste the complex flavors of traditional spices and chocolate. Great empanadas, burritos and tortas. Polite and attentive service.
A
Lot of bad things with this place.

1. The food just isn't up to par with other Mexican restaurants in the area. Tacombi is miles ahead in taste.
2. The chips always taste stale. I've tried ordering them five times and they're always stale.
3. They will mess up your online order consistently. All I ordered was a burrito and instead got the plate.
4. The prices are very high compared to competitors.

The only pros I can give this place is they're quick to make your order and the portions are somewhat big. Still wouldn't recommend going here over other places in the area.

Leave a Review

Do you guide private tours here? List your tour for free – no commission, travellers contact you directly.

List your tour for free
Explore More

Nearby Places

You may also like

Similar Places

Related Places