At a glance
#4 of 76 Bakeries in Brooklyn #6 of 61 Cafes in BrooklynLocalGuideWorld score: 4.76
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★91%
-
4 ★5%
-
3 ★1%
-
2 ★0%
-
1 ★3%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Miss American Pie?
- Miss American Pie is rated 4.8 out of 5 based on 193 reviews.
- How does Miss American Pie rank in Brooklyn?
- Miss American Pie is #4 of 76 Bakeries in Brooklyn by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Miss American Pie located?
- 86 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217 — 1.6 km from the center of Brooklyn.
- How can I contact Miss American Pie?
- Phone: (718) 789-3747 · Website: missamericanpienyc.com
Overall rating: 4.7
Cute, classic american diner 70s style for pie. I got the blueberry and strawberry pie (called something?) & vanilla bean ice cream.
I wasn’t expecting the place to be kitschy so that was a lovely surprise. The pie itself was good, but there wasn’t anything special about it. I wasn’t overly obsessed. But I did really like the decorations and staff. I think the ice cream was breyers, can’t remember if they claim being homemade.
It was a cute experience and thought it can be really popular for families and kids. I recommend giving it a try if you enjoy the whole American vibe.
Cute, classic american diner 70s style for pie. I got the blueberry and strawberry pie (called something?) & vanilla bean ice cream.
I wasn’t expecting the place to be kitschy so that was a lovely surprise. The pie itself was good, but there wasn’t anything special about it. I wasn’t overly obsessed. But I did really like the decorations and staff. I think the ice cream was breyers, can’t remember if they claim being homemade.
It was a cute experience and thought it can be really popular for families and kids. I recommend giving it a try if you enjoy the whole American vibe.
Stopped in get my fill of one of my favorite pies. I came in too late as many of the other varieties were sold out. Staff was very nice but the pie was served cold (should have asked if they could warm it up). I don't think I'll necessarily return but I understand the appeal.
Very cute cafe with simply the best pie. Up there with Bubby’s pies (iykyk). Chicken pot pie was a perfect savory treat and i followed with the signature fruit pie and ice cream. The crust on both were moist, flavorful, buttery but not too buttery. I’ll definitely be back.
We have been going here for years, and have never been disappointed. My favorite is the signature pie, but there really isn’t one I wouldn’t enjoy. Try the biscuit, too!
The best Coconut Cream Pie I’ve ever had!!!
Crust is simply scrumptious. The coconut cream is perfection, not overly sweet. 🤤
Crust is simply scrumptious. The coconut cream is perfection, not overly sweet. 🤤
great pie place! so yummy that i forgot to take a pic until i was halfway done with my pie. i tried the signature which had peaches apple and blueberry.
the people working there were really kind too :) it was a nice place to enjoy a pie on a hot summer day.
the people working there were really kind too :) it was a nice place to enjoy a pie on a hot summer day.
This was such a lovely atmosphere!! I went with a friend after dinner for dessert and they had the BEST PIES (I’m not even a pie girlie but I’m CONVERTED) also definitely try the brownie cookie and lattes. Thank You Ryan for the best experience 🫶🏻✨
Best homemade pies in NYC. You can watch the kitchen roll the crust and cut the fruit for Apple, Strawberry Rhubarb, and Peach pies. They also fluff the creams and other fillings in front of you.
The crust has just the right balance of thickness, chew, crunch. Everything super fresh and immaculate, but not sterile. The place has a kitschy Brooklyn diner gone bakeshop vibe. Staff are soooo friendly and welcoming.
We had the Strawberry Rhubarb (perfect balance of fruity/tangy/minimal sweetness) and Chocolate Silk (kind of a dark milk chocolate; creamy but not sweet. Sophisticated). Took slices home too.
The crust has just the right balance of thickness, chew, crunch. Everything super fresh and immaculate, but not sterile. The place has a kitschy Brooklyn diner gone bakeshop vibe. Staff are soooo friendly and welcoming.
We had the Strawberry Rhubarb (perfect balance of fruity/tangy/minimal sweetness) and Chocolate Silk (kind of a dark milk chocolate; creamy but not sweet. Sophisticated). Took slices home too.
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Pure Bistro
View Place
Nacho Macho Taco
View Place
Pizza Secret Ristorante e Pizzeria Napoletana
View Place
Slope Vintage
View Place
Pizza Town
View Place
Convivium Osteria
View Place
Slope Foods inc
View Place
Whistle Work
View Place
Midoriya Japanese Grocery
View Place
Alchemy
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Tarallucci e Vino Upper West Side
View Place
The PanCake Bakery
View Place
Stockholm Inn
View Place
Youngs Farm
View Place
Comparetto Bakery
View Place
Fulton Stall Market
View Place
Foodtown of Crown Heights
View Place
Dessert Gallery Bakery & Cafe
View Place
Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center
View Place