Established Madison Square Garden-area staple serving pizzas whole and by the slice.
At a glance
#20 of 254 Italian restaurants in New York #8 of 124 Pizza restaurants in New YorkLocalGuideWorld score: 4.60
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★73%
-
4 ★17%
-
3 ★5%
-
2 ★2%
-
1 ★3%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of NY Pizza Suprema?
- NY Pizza Suprema is rated 4.6 out of 5 based on 7,008 reviews.
- How does NY Pizza Suprema rank in New York?
- NY Pizza Suprema is #20 of 254 Italian restaurants in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is NY Pizza Suprema located?
- 413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001, United States — 0.7 km from the center of New York.
- How can I contact NY Pizza Suprema?
- Phone: +1 212-594-8939 · Website: nypizzasuprema.com
This has been one of my favorite slice places for years, bc their red sauce has such a great flavor.
Lesser pizza places (cough Ray’s cough) smear some unseasoned tomato paste or sauce straight out of the foodservice can onto a dense and frequently undercooked (thus: doughy) crust, and top that with globs of generic cheese that bake into a thick rubbery mass… and then call themselves “famous”. 🙄
Don’t your tastebuds deserve better than that?
NYPS makes a great plain slice & variations, but if you really want to taste a bread & sauce showcase, get the Upside Down Slice. I normally shy away from thick-crust pizza, but since the cheese is placed beneath that delicious sauce, the focaccia-like crust is airy, cloud-like and crisp, not soggy and sad.
If you’re at the Garden for a show, or catching a train/ doing anything remotely nearby- this is your pizza spot! The staff is great, always efficient & friendly and it’s fun to watch them masterfully toss/stretch the dough for the pizzas that I hope they never stop making. ❤️🍕
Lesser pizza places (cough Ray’s cough) smear some unseasoned tomato paste or sauce straight out of the foodservice can onto a dense and frequently undercooked (thus: doughy) crust, and top that with globs of generic cheese that bake into a thick rubbery mass… and then call themselves “famous”. 🙄
Don’t your tastebuds deserve better than that?
NYPS makes a great plain slice & variations, but if you really want to taste a bread & sauce showcase, get the Upside Down Slice. I normally shy away from thick-crust pizza, but since the cheese is placed beneath that delicious sauce, the focaccia-like crust is airy, cloud-like and crisp, not soggy and sad.
If you’re at the Garden for a show, or catching a train/ doing anything remotely nearby- this is your pizza spot! The staff is great, always efficient & friendly and it’s fun to watch them masterfully toss/stretch the dough for the pizzas that I hope they never stop making. ❤️🍕
The best slice I had while visiting.
And I visited maybe more than a handful on the weeks journey.
Selfish sacrifice.
I love there is line busting out the door.
The puzzle was exceptionally fresh.
I had the hot honey slice with a Diet Coke.
The dough was unique in that it was crisp but it bit more like a crackly pastry than a bread pizza dough. It was exceptionally thin, firm and had a wonderful topping of ricotta, hot honey and other cheeses.
I would’ve appreciate some spice from like a crispy spicy pepperoni but their hot honey slice is different here. No meat, no tomato sauce. Which I prefer but this place still beat out other slices that included those preferences.
Love nyc because every shop has a vegan slice.
My friend tried 4 different slices.
Appreciate it not only taste better than most the hyped up spots but you don’t have to wait in a crazy line for pretty good pizza.
It’s no wait for great pizza.
And I visited maybe more than a handful on the weeks journey.
Selfish sacrifice.
I love there is line busting out the door.
The puzzle was exceptionally fresh.
I had the hot honey slice with a Diet Coke.
The dough was unique in that it was crisp but it bit more like a crackly pastry than a bread pizza dough. It was exceptionally thin, firm and had a wonderful topping of ricotta, hot honey and other cheeses.
I would’ve appreciate some spice from like a crispy spicy pepperoni but their hot honey slice is different here. No meat, no tomato sauce. Which I prefer but this place still beat out other slices that included those preferences.
Love nyc because every shop has a vegan slice.
My friend tried 4 different slices.
Appreciate it not only taste better than most the hyped up spots but you don’t have to wait in a crazy line for pretty good pizza.
It’s no wait for great pizza.
Came into the city off the train and had to come get something to eat immediately! Servers were great and friendly. Went with a BBQ chicken and it came super hot, had to let it cool off. Every bite had a piece of chicken and was sauce/cheese was perfect. Little pricey but if you want to get ya pizza fix off the train this is the place to go.
Super cute place! Line moved quickly. Maybe it’s just the New York way but felt rushed through the line. Pizza could’ve been a little warmer.
Bathroom is tiny.
Pepperoni was the favorite!
Bathroom is tiny.
Pepperoni was the favorite!
Sure, there's Joes & Rays Famous Pizza but NY Pizza Suprema holds its own. Classic New York thin slice, perfect bruciato crunch but not dry, passed the fold test, fresh quality ingredients, friendly guys working hard and serving customers with courtesy & class. The pizza is excellent, reasonably priced, no complaints. Very convenient before a game at MSG or getting off the train at Penn Station. Support your local pizzerias & small businesses 👍
Been going here for the better part of 15 years. I’ve noticed a very large dip in quality in the past 3 years. This includes sauce flavor, crisp to the dough and ingredient displacement and amount. Went back a couple weeks ago, saw they had a B and now I probably won’t be back. Way better pizza all throughout the city. 7.1 Overpriced and sloppy pizza. See attached are photos of the exact same two slices of pizza taken 5 years apart.
Went before heading to MSG as it’s across the road. Pizza slice was sturdy (didn’t crumble under the weight of toppings) which is impressive given size. Sausage was the winner followed by fig/bacon and then ricotta/honey. Managed to snag a table but people tend to not linger so outside super peak probably manageable. Not a lot of standing counter space though so if you don’t get a table not sure where you go!? Would happily return.
Simple and best NY style pizza in NY. Quick service, good ambience. Tried all the veggie options and they turned out to be great especially the Hot Honey pizza.
Portion sizes are huge. Value for money. Felt full after a single slice.
Portion sizes are huge. Value for money. Felt full after a single slice.
Leave a Review
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
Blarney Stone
View Place
Panda Express
View Place
Universal Write Publications
View Place
24hoursPlumberNYC
View Place
Kleinmann Architects
View Place
Chinese Television System
View Place
Molly Wee
View Place
Campus Education
View Place
Gardenia Deli
View Place
New York City Protective Services
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Tarallucci e Vino Upper West Side
View Place
Officina at The Wharf
View Place
TESSA
View Place
Osteria Cotta
View Place
Lucciola
View Place
Trattoria iL Gusto Wine Bar
View Place
Bella Luna Restaurant
View Place
Bosphorus Restaurant
View Place
Sorrento's Pizza House
View Place