Mary Fh
Latest Reviews
NY Pizza Suprema
2024 May 26
This has been one of my favorite slice places for years, bc their red sauce has such a great flavor.
Lesser pizza places (cough Ray’s cough) smear some unseasoned tomato paste or sauce straight out of the foodservice can onto a dense and frequently undercooked (thus: doughy) crust, and top that with globs of generic cheese that bake into a thick rubbery mass… and then call themselves “famous”. 🙄
Don’t your tastebuds deserve better than that?
NYPS makes a great plain slice & variations, but if you really want to taste a bread & sauce showcase, get the Upside Down Slice. I normally shy away from thick-crust pizza, but since the cheese is placed beneath that delicious sauce, the focaccia-like crust is airy, cloud-like and crisp, not soggy and sad.
If you’re at the Garden for a show, or catching a train/ doing anything remotely nearby- this is your pizza spot! The staff is great, always efficient & friendly and it’s fun to watch them masterfully toss/stretch the dough for the pizzas that I hope they never stop making. ❤️🍕
Lesser pizza places (cough Ray’s cough) smear some unseasoned tomato paste or sauce straight out of the foodservice can onto a dense and frequently undercooked (thus: doughy) crust, and top that with globs of generic cheese that bake into a thick rubbery mass… and then call themselves “famous”. 🙄
Don’t your tastebuds deserve better than that?
NYPS makes a great plain slice & variations, but if you really want to taste a bread & sauce showcase, get the Upside Down Slice. I normally shy away from thick-crust pizza, but since the cheese is placed beneath that delicious sauce, the focaccia-like crust is airy, cloud-like and crisp, not soggy and sad.
If you’re at the Garden for a show, or catching a train/ doing anything remotely nearby- this is your pizza spot! The staff is great, always efficient & friendly and it’s fun to watch them masterfully toss/stretch the dough for the pizzas that I hope they never stop making. ❤️🍕