Cozy, rustic Italian restaurant featuring seafood & vegetarian dishes, plus cocktails & 2 bars.
At a glance
#70 of 254 Italian restaurants in New YorkLocalGuideWorld score: 4.50
Rating breakdown
-
5 ★75%
-
4 ★12%
-
3 ★6%
-
2 ★4%
-
1 ★4%
Quick facts
- What is the rating of Osteria 57?
- Osteria 57 is rated 4.5 out of 5 based on 634 reviews.
- How does Osteria 57 rank in New York?
- Osteria 57 is #70 of 254 Italian restaurants in New York by LocalGuideWorld score (rating weighted by number of reviews).
- Where is Osteria 57 located?
- 57 W 10th St, New York, NY 10011 — 2.2 km from the center of New York.
- How can I contact Osteria 57?
- Phone: (212) 777-0057 · Website: osteria57.com
A quaint and cozy Italian restaurant! The ambiance is nice. It's good for a date or to be with friends. It's more on the quiet side. They have warm houses if you want to dine outside. The service is great. The team is observant. The drinks and food come to the table fairly quickly. Everything was tasty. We tried the lobster dish and the black sea bass. The cauliflower app and the app with the calamari are also really good! I recommend this place!!
What a great find! This is such a cozy place with an intimate vibe. The food was delicious! I had the fusili with mushrooms and scallops and my friend had the cacao and pepe pasta. For dessert we ordered the tiramisu and millefoglie. Everything was very good and portions were just right! The staff were so friendly and were so apologetic when we were asked to move since another group had arrived for their reset. I can appreciate a restaurant that respects reservation times! We gladly moved to the bar and had a great time there. I'll definitely be back!
Exceptional service starting from the hostess to the waiters and manager.
It’s hard to find a good Italian restaurant in the city due to the fact that most places are converted to Italian-American now-days.
The plates were very creative and absolutely delicious. The crudo of the day was out favorite choice. Great overall experience!
It’s hard to find a good Italian restaurant in the city due to the fact that most places are converted to Italian-American now-days.
The plates were very creative and absolutely delicious. The crudo of the day was out favorite choice. Great overall experience!
Osteria57 was a really wonderful dining experience. Very romantic and service was courteous and pleasant, while also efficient but not rushed. Really great date night spot. Would really recommend the pasta option with pistachio pesto (believe me even though the picture I took doesn't do it justice).
Absolutely a 5 star quality food experience. Their drinks and wine selection is perfection and an Italophile’s paradise. We had the watermelon salad, ricotta truffle toast (well worth the $$), the salmon and paccheri with burrata to eat. Our server could have been friendlier, he seemed annoyed when we asked questions but everyone else was extremely welcoming and the environment is very homey and just lovely. Also, please note it can get very loud in the dining room and quite warm in the back room so opt for outdoor seating if you’d like to hear each other easily. Came with a friend, will definitely come back with my husband. 👍
Wow… just wow. Osteria 57 was INCREDIBLE!
My wife and I came for brunch and absolutely loved it. Dario, the head of the restaurant came and chatted with us a bit, here’s what we learned/ my impressions:
1. All of the food from Osteria 57 is pescatarian and seasonal. The menu changes year round based on what’s available at high quality.
2. All of the fruits and vegetables are locally sourced from organic farms. The seafood is all caught by local fisherman. They were particularly proud of their five different types of cherry tomatoes 🍅
3. THE WATERMELON SALAD!! Omg!!
4. ALSO THE TRULLE RICOTTA TOAST!! Wow!!
5. You can taste the freshness. And it leaves you not feeling heavy. Sometimes you eat somewhere and it makes you feel heavy and bloated. Here, I ate quite a bit and didn’t feel that at all. I felt light and very satisfied.
6. Most of the recipes are very selective about which ingredients are used. Ingredients are chosen sparingly and for maximum effort and taste. It’s simple and complex at the same time.
7. Just good vibes all around. All of the service people and owners that we talked to were so kind. I would definitely recommend Osteria 57 to anyone.
My wife and I came for brunch and absolutely loved it. Dario, the head of the restaurant came and chatted with us a bit, here’s what we learned/ my impressions:
1. All of the food from Osteria 57 is pescatarian and seasonal. The menu changes year round based on what’s available at high quality.
2. All of the fruits and vegetables are locally sourced from organic farms. The seafood is all caught by local fisherman. They were particularly proud of their five different types of cherry tomatoes 🍅
3. THE WATERMELON SALAD!! Omg!!
4. ALSO THE TRULLE RICOTTA TOAST!! Wow!!
5. You can taste the freshness. And it leaves you not feeling heavy. Sometimes you eat somewhere and it makes you feel heavy and bloated. Here, I ate quite a bit and didn’t feel that at all. I felt light and very satisfied.
6. Most of the recipes are very selective about which ingredients are used. Ingredients are chosen sparingly and for maximum effort and taste. It’s simple and complex at the same time.
7. Just good vibes all around. All of the service people and owners that we talked to were so kind. I would definitely recommend Osteria 57 to anyone.
I’ve enjoyed every about this place. The food is well presented and tasty. You can see from the photos that the chefs put a lot thought and care behind each dish.
The waiter and the host were secessional, very friendly and welcoming.
The atmosphere is very relaxing, either inside the restaurant or outside. We had a table in the outside cabin, which was air con and you feel very much apart of the inside vibe.
I see a lot of the reviewers mentioned about the price and the portions. I think maybe the cocktails could be cheaper, but the food is totally in price range for the quality and the experience that you get.
I would definitely recommend and I will definitely return.
The waiter and the host were secessional, very friendly and welcoming.
The atmosphere is very relaxing, either inside the restaurant or outside. We had a table in the outside cabin, which was air con and you feel very much apart of the inside vibe.
I see a lot of the reviewers mentioned about the price and the portions. I think maybe the cocktails could be cheaper, but the food is totally in price range for the quality and the experience that you get.
I would definitely recommend and I will definitely return.
Sooo happy we got to try this place while visiting nyc! It was the best dinner experience - two Italian waiters / maybe owners (?) - greeted us warmly, chatted with us, and explained the menu with wine pairing, top service. And the food was amazing- best pasta I’ve ever had in a restaurant. The vibe is really cool low light and small cozy space. I would def recommend it to someone wanting a romantic dinner or cool hangout with friends.
Indoor/outdoor. They have outdoor cabin options as well and a small table outside that was really cool and candlelit at night.
Indoor/outdoor. They have outdoor cabin options as well and a small table outside that was really cool and candlelit at night.
Explore More
Nearby Places
View Place
57 West 10th Street
View Place
Alta
View Place
The Villager
View Place
Village Vintner Inc
View Place
West 10th Street Apartments
View Place
Yamadaya
View Place
La Contenta Oeste
View Place
Bascom Real Estate
View Place
Kubeh
View Place
9 St
You may also like
Similar Places
View Place
Tarallucci e Vino Upper West Side
View Place
Officina at The Wharf
View Place
TESSA
View Place
Osteria Cotta
View Place
Lucciola
View Place
Trattoria iL Gusto Wine Bar
View Place
Bella Luna Restaurant
View Place
Bosphorus Restaurant
View Place
Sorrento's Pizza House
View Place